American tourist “Taiwan is not a country, you are Chinese” has gone viral

Who posted it on forumosa?

Because they did report the truth. On the video you posted.

In the video you sent me, all it says this girl posted this picture to social media and described it and then described reactions to the post. One such reaction questioned if it was AI.

What exactly did the news misrepresent?

You could, then you’d look pretty foolish for lying.


FAKE NEWS!!11!!1111!!!


Maybe this is true. Maybe this is not. Fact checking is for investigative journalism.


Did the post not exist when it was reported on? I don’t think you really understand how journalism works.

Hey guys! Look at this post online that someone made praising our country! We like this message and think you should see it too.

Like, what exactly was fake?

Well you can question me even the video featuring the white man deserves questioning as it could just be CCP propaganda as someone already mentioned. However, since the incident supposedly happened in Taiwan, reporters could easily draw an investigation by talking to local police or confirming the man’s identity to verify the facts. While they choose not to dig any deeper because it goes against their interests, the controversial remark came from an outsider especially someone from a friendly nation rather than a local citizen or some pro-China supporter, the media prefers to avoid such investigation.

And I am questioning you.

But all I said is that the video is from Chinese State Media and I’d rather not give them my click, nor views. You told me I was wrong. I proved you wrong lmao.

What do you want reporters to do? Break into her house? Over a post? Reporters report. The journos in this case did their job properly. They reported on the post.

You want all journalism to be investigative journalism.

That video of the girl with the Taiwan sticker is nothing more than recycled internet rumor and obvious AI fabrication. When journalists do such a poor job of verifying it that they end up showcasing a fake image, it highlights just how unworthy the whole thing is of media attention.

WHAT rumour?

What is the rumour?

What did they need to verify?

Someone posted their support for Taiwan on a personal account. If not for anyone else, but for themselves. They exercised their right to free of expression.

They made an AI image. They deceived people for thinking it was an organic encounter. Not the news. The news, particularly the example YOU provided to me expressed it in a factual manner. The news made 0 unverifiable claims.

this dumpster fire thread is making me nostalgic for when you’d just post about your prison time for gun running, and how you could sneak past customs and get back into the country.

That kind of story shouldn’t be making headlines in the first place, as it’s just based on an online AI-generated photo. In contrast, the incident involving the American is genuinely newsworthy because it sheds light on how foreigners perceive the Taiwanese and Chinese identity. However DPP’s media is trying hard to promote the “Taiwanese” and “Anti-China” agenda I’m not surprise that they avoid covering the white man’a incident.

Except that fact was not known initially, and when it was discovered the media corrected the story.

The difference is that it’s already known by everyone (except you apparently) that it’s propaganda, so there’s literally nothing to report - the media did their job by not reporting it!

(Unless you’d rather they reported it just to boost the views for a foreign adversary? Are you on PRC payroll now? :wink: )

In summary, there is no question, there is nothing to see, move along, get on with your day, quit beating the dead fake horse… :roll_eyes:

Leaning into cheap, xenophobic tropes doesn’t make a weak argument any stronger. Try addressing the actual topic instead of using someone’s past incarceration as a cheap punchline or a weaponised stereotype to discredit them.

I deeply love Taiwan, but I don’t support the DPP. I also oppose the CCP, but not China. Above all, I won’t support any political party or system that tries to strip off people’s gun and citizenship rights. I clearly do not support CCP but that doesn’t means I have to be anti China or pro independence. I respect everyone’s freedom of speech no matter you are pro or anti China.

If you like guns, I can think of a few large and aggressive countries you could consider for your next move(s).

Have you looked into serving the Russian Federation? :whistle:

Guy

They even have a get out of jail card :joker:, if you sign a military contract.

I thought we lived in a mixed capitalist society that has the right to a free press.

You just don’t seem to get it, do you? As @bz said, it was not initially, then corrected when it was discovered.

Where are these socalled DPP media? Are they in the room with us right now?

It’s really hard to take these posts seriously when you speak like this. Mostly because you’ve claimed nobody has reported it but blame the DPP anyways for some reason.

Why? Because as you have admitted you don’t like the DPP on numerous occasions and your principle reason being because you got kicked out of Taiwan and upset the government won’t let you back in, it makes it hard to believe that this is more about personal grievances than anything else.

Yeah. We know. You mentioned it in many other posts and then told us that you don’t like them because you can’t get back into Taiwan. Therefore you have hoped the KMT would come back and give all people of Chinese Descent citizenship in Taiwan in hopes that would give you a roundabout way of returning after your gun crime conviction.

Totally not biased at all.

I don’t know why you don’t willingly choose to live in the US then. We don’t have gun rights here, nor very many other places too. I like our safe streets.

Secondly, your citizenship rights were not stripped. Either you’re a citizen, or you’re not.

You’re not.

I mean, it’s either one or the other. Not that difficult.

Please don’t give him any (more) ideas.

All we are missing is DPP regime and Taiwan Island and it’s a full on CCP lovefest.

Somebody caught with guns in China would be stewing in jail for forty years. In fact you may well be executed and your organs harvested.

Be careful what ya wish for, and,uhhm, grow the fuck up out of yer nonsense and bitterness. Move the fuck on. See a therapist, Get a gf and a steady job.

So you call this “free press.” If the Taiwanese media truly has the right to report a pro-Taiwan independence perspectives, why is the opposite, pro-China comments, especially when voiced by a foreigner almost entirely ignored by the DPP media?

When identical pro-China remarks come from Chinese tourists, mainland spouses, or even pro-unification Taiwanese, they are immediately dragged into the spotlight, subject to public criticism and online attacks by the press. Yet, a foreigner expressing the exact same stance is conveniently given a free pass and spared. This double standard exposes how DPP-aligned media weaponising freedom of speech, selectively targeting dissent while shielding their preferred narratives, and you disagree with me.

That’s what press freedom is. The press is free to report on anything it wants.

Who are these ‘DPP media’? Do they exist? Are they in the room with us right now?

Well I do support Ukraine’s armed struggle for sovereignty and deeply value the rights we enjoy in the U.S, but I strongly disagree with specific policies Trump is implementing right now. This is not double standards, my concern comes from the fact that Trump’s current stance and policies are simply not friendly to immigrants and non-citizens.