An open letter to President Chen

Please don’t laugh too hard or make a lot of snide comments, because this is just an open letter I would like to share with everyone. Given my past satisfactory experience in writing to President Chen and the resulting prompt and effective action his office took to respond to my concerns, I hope that more people choose to make the Office of the President aware of things which need addressing. After all, they do seem to listen, and if enough people take the time to talk to politicians here instead of gripe about the quality of life … hey, you never know! It’s okay to be naive and a dreamer, but don’t be apathetic. Best wishes for the holiday season, everyone!

Dear President Chen:

 I am a concerned foreign resident who is wondering why, when I try to follow the letter of your laws and work honestly in my chosen profession, there are other foreign workers in Taiwan who are able to work illegally.  Allow me to explain.  I am an English teacher in Tainan City who, having worked to gain the proper teaching credentials back in my home country of Canada, chose to come to work here in Taiwan.  I eventually married here and have decided to live here for the forseeable future, having bought a house and other such odds and ends.  As such, I have gone through the processes for getting a special work permit, a special visa, etc., so as to work and live legally here in your country, and I try to follow the laws and regulations regarding where I can work and what I can do to the best of my abilities.

 However, I have also noticed and know of many teachers who have not gone through the same processes as myself and who choose to work where they can regardless of if it is legal or illegal.  Not only that, but many cram schools and even public schools are helping these teachers break the law.  Given that I am sure this is happening not just in Tainan but around Taiwan, and given that I am getting more and more disgusted by this practice, I would like to ask you a few questions.  First of all, why is the police not doing anything to stop this practice?  When I went to complain to the police, I was asked to write down my complaint, but that's about it.  I'm not even sure any action was taken.  Second of all, how is it possible that schools which break the law know when the police are coming to do a raid ahead of time, and are thus able to tell their teachers to hide for a couple of hours until the police are gone, and then just go on breaking the law?  This is a small example of the "black gold" you would like to stamp out, as the only explanation for this situation is that elected/bureaucratic officials are being bribed to give out warnings to businesses/schools (or, even worse, just plain "selling" such information) in advance of such raids in return for kickbacks/other services.  Third of all, how can the foreign community in Taiwan take your government's regulations seriously if they are never applied in a just and responsible fashion?  For instance, if a teacher can work illegally, what will stop them from driving illegally, too?  Or opening an illegal business?  Can you honestly tell me that this is not a problem?  

 Now, I know the probable answer to all of my preceding questions will be something like "we don't have the manpower, it takes time to implement new laws, etc," and those are indeed reasonable arguments.  However, during the time that we wait for such measures to be properly implemented, or because of the lack of manpower, many foreigners here in Taiwan for a short period of time are giving long-term foreign residents a bad reputation with their irresponsible actions.  In addition, your government is missing out on a chance to stamp out rampant corruption in the education industry at the local/municipal level, corruption which both debilitates the learning ability of Taiwanese children as well as makes Taiwanese parents and law-abiding foreign teachers angry.  

 May I make a suggestion?  Is it possible to work with some select foreign residents in different cities who would, working with the police, go to school after school to root out such corruption?  This arrangement would take care of the manpower issue for the police, and the resulting crackdown on illegal practices would bring in much needed revenue for your government (by way of fines) as well as show the world that the Taiwanese people are world leaders in the education industry.  A successful program in the education industry could then be extended to other facets of the Taiwanese economy, thereby making Taiwan's economy more efficient and productive and the envy of many other countries, both developed and less developed.  

 Mr. President, I am just speaking out as a single voice, and I realize that I have no vote.  I don't own a business with any interest in seeing this situation rectified, or have any other financial interest involved.  But, this is my adopted country, I will be raising my family here, and I would like to raise my family in a country both they, and I, can be proud of.  I was very happy to receive prompt action from you and your office in response to my previous letter regarding stolen motorcycles, and I hope that the same will happen once again.  Thank you for your time and consideration, and best wishes for the holiday season to you and your family from both myself and my family.

  Sincerely, 

                                                              Patrick Kelaiditis
                                                              [pk.sbony@msa.hinet.net](mailto:pk.sbony@msa.hinet.net)

You put your real name on this.
Don’t post this over at Tealit or they will all be hunting you down.
I just take the attitude of the Taiwanese, if it doesn’t hurt or affect me then I’ll just leave it alone.
You’re not exactly going to make a lot of friends here.
What are you suggesting, a foreign arm of the Taiwanese FBI.
I know an agent of the Taiwan FBI (well along the lines of the FBI anyway) in Tainan, I’ll ask him what he thinks shall I?

I am not a violent person, but if I met a foreigner who worked with the police to hunt down and deport other foreigners, I would lay some smack down just on general principle. Patrick, with all the shit going on in Taiwan, why does it bother you so bad that some people are working illegally?

I’m not looking for an FBI sort of deal, just some show of concern out of the authorities. Why should guilty people benefit from the apathy prevalent here, or the “look the other way because I’m getting some money under the table and who really cares anyway” mindset of the authorities? As for myself, I don’t worry about what other people think, because after all, they are entitled to their own opinion. But, don’t some of the things going on in this country make anyone else sick? Comment away, but at least make the people in charge aware of things, otherwise they will never change!!

You were a hall monitor in high school, weren’t you?
Computer club?
Chess club?

I am a legal worker here in Taiwan and also married to a Taiwanese, but I can think of far better things to write to the president about. Since the Pres. listens to you perhaps you should check out Richard Hartzells website and find some useful things to write about on there.

Yeah Patrick, and you could change your name. Henri-Philippe Petain has a kind of nice ring to it, don’t you think? Would we get to have uniforms? Or would it be more along the lines of trenchcoats and snap-brim fedoras? I can’t shake the image of Donald Sutherland’s screaming face at the end of Invasion of the Bodysnatchers. And would we get a salary for this? Getting paid to snitch on 22 year old South Africans sounds a lot more fun than editing. Where do I sign up?

Becareful Sandman, Spiny Norman has a loyal following of 22 year old South Africans. You could be causing yourself (I mean Spiny Norman) severe financial loss.

Why do I get the feeling that there is something you are not telling us, Patrick? There has got to be more to this story. Nobody is that concerned with something as harmless as illegal workers without an agenda. Time to talk to the Tainan folks to get the scoop.

Interesting idea… Those cram school owners are well connected and might cause you some trouble… especially in Hualian. I only advocate making waves here, when doing so doesn’t set you up for an encounter the local mob in less than friendly circumstances.

Sorry Boss, I forgot to add the :unamused: at the end of my last post. Where I come from, people like Patrick are called grasses and no-one is unhappy when they get pounded flat or worse, as they invariably do, eventually. Absolutely the scummiest lowest of the low.

I’m with chainsmoker on this one… why does it bother you? It doesn’t affect you, or your job. And not all illegal foreign workers here are the same people who give Westerners a bad name. The people who give the rest of us a bad reputation are often those long-term legal workers who have lost all (or never had any) respect for Taiwan or the Taiwanese, and do nothing here but sleeze onto young girls, start fights, get very rich and fat, and all the while, make absolutely no attempt to learn Chinese. Isn’t this kind of person (your kin) far more despicable than a struggling student, or someone in the middle of some sort of transition looking for a bit of cash to make their life more liveable?

Here’s something for your letter: Why not suggest that the MOE increase all scholarships granted by, say $20,000 per month, and make the tests more challenging than just some pussy interview. I guarantee that if that happened, you’d see a huge chunk fall away from the illegal English teaching population.

Now, admittedly, I have about as much respect for illegal workers, doing nothing but illegal work as you do, but if they all suddenly left, what would happen to Taiwan’s already apalling English standards? (Personally, I don’t care about Taiwan’s English standard, but I’m assuming do.) I understand why you would want to write such a letter, but again, why?

-Dave :smiley:

Nope, Boss Hogg, none of the above. Didn’t have the time. I was working in a gas station and warehouse as soon as I turned 16 to fund my university education since my family didn’t have the money to put me through. I worked during the night and went to school during the day, and continued that schedule all the way through university. So, I know the value of a hard-earned, honestly earned, dollar. Regarding Mr. Hartzell, I have indeed asked him for clarification on some issues simply because I wanted to do things the right, legal way. I again offer my thanks to Richard, by the way.

 Sandman, ratting out people is not my style, and neither is mafia-type action or dress ... itwas just a suggestion.  Essentially, I'm just a caring person who likes to live in a safe, legal way and hopes others can do the same.  I worked hard to pay off my mortgage here, to learn the language, to make a life for myself, and to deal with the various governmental agencies here on a daily/weekly/monthly basis.  Take what I wrote with a grain of salt, and offer some constructive advice for a would-be activist like myself.  Don't just open your mouth and say things which only show what a fool you really are.

Oh, right. You’d rather some other sucker took responsibility for the dirty side of things. Niiiiice.

[quote=“pkelaiditis”]
First of all, why is the police not doing anything to stop this practice? When I went to complain to the police, I was asked to write down my complaint, but that’s about it. I’m not even sure any action was taken. [/quote]

Hmmmm…

LazyMF, you make some good points, but your own apathy comes through in your response loud and clear. In fact, I hate to say it, but there is no constructive information being offered thus far in response to my open letter, just a lot of, as I thought would be the case, snide comments, bad attitude, useless innuendo and other such junk. Keep it coming, people, but I’m still on the lookout for some constructive information.

Patrick,

I recommend that you drop the letter idea. I think that if people want to work illegally here then that’s their problem.

I also think you owe Sandman an apology. After reading your letter, you shouldn’t be calling anybody a “fool”.

And, in terms of my complaint to the police, lest you get the wrong idea, I filled out the form because I found out a school I was just starting to work for had illegally hired me, and I didn’t want them to get away with breaking the law. And, yes, I intend to follow through with my complaint because I am a serious teacher who puts his heart and soul into teaching and would like to work for someone who not only feels the same way as myself (hard to find sometimes in Taiwan, I admit) but is also a legal employer.

Daplidakus wrote:
Essentially, I’m just a caring person who likes to live in a safe, legal way and hopes others can do the same.

Canada is a safe and ordered country. Why don’t you try and find some safety and order there you turncoat, you…

Remember that in Taiwan DAD is in charge.

Most of us like it that way.

Sorry, but I can’t oblige you on either of these requests.

If you are so much better a teacher than your illegal rivals, they should be no competition for you. If you aren’t under pressure financially from these illegals, then may I also suggest you find something more important to bring to A-Bian’s attention?

OTOH, maybe you should go post this on tealit, but please remember to include your home address, phone number and details of any dark alleys you walk down and at what times. Live and let live.

(Before you jump to any conclusions, I’m not a teacher and am not involved in the industry, legally or illegally)

And, for Durin’s Bane, if writing to express my opinion in an open forum for everyone to read and respond to, be it positively or negatively, makes me a fool, then I guess I am guilty as charged. But, if you want to get into name calling, then I’ll sink to your level … I guess it takes one to know one, eh? Keep it coming.