Looked at from one angle or another, there’s enough blame in this situation to go around for everyone, Republicans, Democracts, national authorities, local authorities, and some ordinary, local citizens caught up in the mess.
Although I haven’t researched it exhaustively (be realistic, who has time or energy for that on every thread?), I accept that the chain of responsibility basically follows this sequence: individual, family, neighborhood, city, state, and nation. I had no intention of avoiding or denying that in any of my comments so far. I assumed it was a given and understood by all.
That said, during times of overwhelming tragedy, based on some shared moral code, doesn’t an obligation, if not a legal responsibility, fall to those with the capability to respond? I think it does. Many other instances within the U.S. on a daily basis, and in the aftermath of this event, support this concept. Those who can, should. Many who could, did. Not everyone mind you. But there was the heavy equipment operator who drove to the levee breach and started working on it. There were neighbors rescuing each other in boats. Despite the obvious commercial benefits, there was WalMart driving the truckloads of supplies into the city. Even the actor and activist Sean Penn tried to drive a leaking boat in to help. And countless other examples of which we’ll only ever know a small fraction. All of these things happened and are still happening without any legal obligation. Without any hassle or argument about hierarchy or responsibility or response time. These things happened because the people who could do them decided to do them.
I suspect that, underneath much of the disillusionment and/or anger about this situation that of course extends far beyond these often petty forums to the whole of the nation and much of the world, is exactly this issue. Regardless of who’s responsible for what, the federal government had more capability than any local entity (and more than most other nations for that matter). That is unquestionable. Why then, based on the same morals, values, judgments, and compunctions did the federal agencies and personalities not respond in the same way – immediately and with everything they could muster? Don’t talk to me about faster than Hurricane Andrew or the mayor needs to ask. If your neighbor’s house is on fire, you don’t ask him to fill out a form before you’ll help him. Almost everyone seems to get that except the federal government. And many people are some combination of embarrassed, ashamed, and trying to figure out why the federal government doesn’t get it – this concept shared almost instinctively by ordinary people.