Can China invade Taiwan successfully?

Technically, technically, all Taiwanese are chinese for chinar and all chinese are ROC nationals for TW.

After that no clue what u r talking about, no idea how a prohibition on direct CNY-TWD conversion would do anything, u just route twdusd and then usdcny.

You clearly missed the ROK presidents speech to Congress last month.

They will totally fight. Dog on leash.

1 Like

How long do you think Yoon will stick around? That would be one variable to consider here.

Guy

No Chinese passport…no entry to China.

Oh yes, may be convenient for awhile on some secondary markets to exchange to RMB. But just imagine if this year’s rate to exchange to RMB is attractive…luring people to hedge and put money in RMB…meanwhile the Taiwan economy in a tailspin. The NTD value will plummet against all currencies…speed to exchange your NTD is paramount.

Never heard of the taiwanese compatriot permit “taibaozheng”?

Tbh, as long as TW keeps exporting, there will be demand for TWD. So there must be a military cohercive action to stop exports, like a blockade. Luring with attractive FX rate not seeing it as a cohercive measures and that effective.

No idea. You think the next guy will not be strongly pro American, guy?

The two parties swing back and forth, with Yoon and the conservatives leaning to the US. It is possible though that the obnoxious wolf warrior approach taken by Beijing in Korea may put an end to this wobbling!

Guy

Ya think?

It may have all started here . . . :rofl:

Guy

If China makes the attempt, what will follow is a humiliating defeat for China. The PRC will become the Former People’s Republic of China, splitting into a dozen or more countries under the interim control of New NATO. The irony will be that with the defeat and collapse of the CCP, it will once again be a good opportunity to manufacture in Former China, with a more competitive market in Asia. Businesses will return in droves due to many years worth of prior infrastructure investments (if the CCP doesn’t sabotage everything on their retreat. The economy will grow dramatically during this period - spurred by the easing of present inflationary policies.

Then there will be Nuremberg-type trials for the CCP leadership, and the world will rejoice.

Have you mentioned this to Joint Chief of Staff members in D.C.?
They might not know this.

1 Like

According to surveys they somehow made China more disliked than Japan, which is an almost Herculean task considering how much Koreans hate the Japanese.

1 Like

None of the Japanese people I socialize with here in Japan have the slightest desire to go to war with China over Taiwan. Don’t know if it’s true but one friend told me at lunch the other day that a recent poll found 11% of Japanese people are in favor of war if China attacks Taiwan.

How much do you think Korea would be involved in a war? What did he say? Of course Korea has US bases but it’s unlikely to be involved in a war

Anyway it’s not that relevant .

I don’t want to be in a dog fight, I live in Taiwan

Yeah that’s completely irrelevant

Decisions to go to war don’t depend on plebiscites.

Japan won’t be involved in a war because of brotherhood with Taiwan, Japan will go to war because it’s likely to be next afterwards

3 Likes

Don’t take drugs

We literally have no idea what the result of a hot war will be between the US and China

You can make up fantasy stories but we don’t know. We have no idea. Nothing . No idea

Also China has nuclear weapons

2 Likes

What do you think is the second and third biggest air force in the world?

With The United States Air Force obviously being number one

History says otherwise. If public support for war in a democracy evaporates politicians pay heed or fall in the next election.

History says decisions to join a war are dependent on referendum?

Good luck if you’re counting on Japan to defend Taiwan:

A full 80% of the 3,000 adults interviewed by the Asahi Shimbun daily newspaper recently expressed concern that Japan would become caught up in the conflict if Beijing were to attack Taiwan in an effort to unify it with the Chinese mainland.

Political analysts and members of the public from across Japan’s political spectrum said they were “not at all surprised” at the outcome of the poll.

It is widely expected that the US would go to Taiwan’s aid in the event of any such assault. The government in Tokyo, which is at present presiding over a massive increase in arms spending, has in the past stated that a Chinese invasion of the island would pose a critical threat to Japan too, as it would leave Beijing in control of the sea lanes used to transport 90% of the nation’s energy needs and 60% of its food supplies.

Tokyo has not explicitly stated that it would commit ground, air or maritime units to help fend off any Chinese attack; but soaring defense spending and the upgrading of Japan’s naval and air capabilities, in particular, indicate that the military is preparing itself.

Rear-echelon support for US forces only

The increased expenditure has triggered a domestic debate on what Japan’s role might be in a conflict, with 56% of those polled by Asahi saying that the Japan Self-Defense Forces (JSDF) should be limited to providing rear-echelon support to US forces, such as assistance with fuel, food and medical aid, as well as logistics. Just 11% said the Japanese military should join forces with the US to repel the invasion.
– Japan: Public reluctant to defend Taiwan should China invade – DW – 05/11/2023