My own singing possibly.
Also this. He sings very well here of course, within the range of his own limits.
Dylan decided that he wanted to be unique and instantly identifiable, so he adopted that odd singing style. Itās not his natural voice. Donovan copied that from him.
Tom Waits and Cohen are natural baritones, and both storytellers. Their voices, whilst not technically perfect, define their personas. Nick Cave is dreadfully flat most of the time, but when we hear it, we know instantly that itās him. He also tells stories (mostly, admittedly, banal).
What people perceive as affected whininess from Neil Young is actually his natural voice. Heās out of tune most of the time. But who cares? He writes great songs.
And good singing can be learned. Myself, as an example, could never be a soprano Thatās physiological. but I have, through years of practice, at least learned how to hold a tune and sing in key.
I think itās a lot more about passion and will than genetics. If you donāt want to be a great pianist, painter, etc., then you wonāt be.
7 Likes
Iād add that if one listens to Dylan croon in a song like Lay Lady Lay for example, they might get a bit of a different impression.
3 Likes
1 Like
As much as I think she never uses the true power of her voice, i believe Taylor Swift was the love child of a stock broker and a marketing executive.
If she continues on her latest trend of going back to being a country singer I might give her music a bit more than a cursory glance.
2 Likes
He did an album when he stopped smoking. Totally unrecognizable. Then he hits the sticks again. whew.
1 Like
Thatās the lockdown talking. Yer out your mind.
And just to put this out there, NONE of the Grateful Dead could sing to save the tour. Hornsby was a kind and sweet interlude though in the early 90s.
Hereās Jerry backing Bruce, the way it should have been in a perfect and boring world.
Sinatra was an impeccable singer.
3 Likes
This. He did it intentionally because he wanted people focusing on the lyrics and not his voice.
Hereās another one he sings in a more conventional voice.
2 Likes
And another, with another good singer!
2 Likes
That is true , we all have an innate singing range, but all can improve and with the right teacher in a dramatic fashion.
1 Like
Interesting. I canāt stand Donovan, either.
Let us not forget dear Kateā¦ This must also be the cheapest music video.ever filmed too.
āKate wear this red dress , take this mushroom tea, and sing on the Moors at first light.ā
2 Likes
Oh, I dunno aboot that:
3 Likes
Russell Watson
Only Mick Jagger could get away with that shirt colour. I loved this when it came out , but now ummmm not so.sure 
This is right about the time when Bianca caught Mick and Dave in bed, dancing in the sheetsā¦NOT that thereās anything wrong with that! whewā¦almost got cancelled!
2 Likes
They look like they are having a coronaparty in that video.
1 Like
Is that true? Mick is no Marc Almond. 