MoI is planning to change the ID Number format

The staff at NHI are trying to persuade me and my employer not to update the ID number with NHI as the old one is still printed on the back of the ARC/APRC and is valid for 10 years.
I insisted to update it as I want all my stuff to be consistent. It’s just 200 TWD for a new NHI card anyway.

You can show them the text from the form:

健保署於受理並完成變更資料時,將註銷原使用之健保卡,故請保險對象另填「請領健保卡申請表」,並繳交工本費200元,申請換發新卡。
※表列已申報提繳勞工退休金之人員,本表並為勞工退休金勞工資料變更申請書。

NHI staff can complain to MOI for that great idea of changing the ID number (without making anything better).

3 Likes

That summarises this sad topic very well. Crazy to use non-random numbers as well - especially since we do have experts like Audrey here.

Maybe it’s like I feel it’s in Germany: there’s experts, sure. But lawmakers often just don’t listen to them.

1 Like

It is just a continuation of bad habits. Taiwanese national’s ID numbers are also incremental. But there are 24m Taiwanese, so they get lost in the crowd and chances are less likely for the ID number to be abused by fraudsters.

Here is a form of abuse I can imagine:

There are websites which collect mug shot pictures in the US and post them with the name and charges publicly. Even if a person was cleared of all charges, that mug shot remains online.
They have a second business which claims to be able to remove those mug shots for a fee.
A vile business model.

Well you could generate all valid IDs and put them online, Google searchable. If a Taiwanese person happens to Google their ID, it will show them a page where it sensationalizes that their ID has been ‘leaked’ and they can remove it from view for a fee. Some might be unhappy about their ID posted publicly and indeed pay the small fee.
If a small percentage of 24m Taiwanese were to pay that, you still end up with a sizable amount of money for not too much work.
Obviously that will get you as much scrutiny from Taiwanese government as possible. But I doubt this to be illegal.

A side note: A group who did those mugshot websites were convicted of fraud and extortion in the US. Do not recommend :happy_frog:

1 Like

No fee. But why not write a script and upload on GitHub. Email the repo link to appropriate government departments and at Taiwan news :slight_smile:

No extortion but exposure. It’s GitHub so no fraud by you. The person has to run the code themselves.

Such libraries exist for a long time. Just modify to generate incremental IDs instead of random.

I even did a small fix commit to that one :happy_frog:

public function personalIdentityNumber($gender = null){...}

2 Likes

Cool. So they’re incorrigible. Well nothing else to do but accept the system made by “experts”

I can see the Taiwan News headline now: “Foreign hacker exposes Taiwan ID numbers online”

Famous quote of German Federal Minister of the Interior:

1 Like

Has anyone ever asked why we have to pay for the new NHI card or driver license when we go to update our numbers? I know the amount we have to pay is pretty low, but I was just wondering. It’s not like we have a choice in getting a new ID number.

4 Likes

Yeah! The government screwed this shit up! They should pay!

3 Likes