[quote=“gao_bo_han”]In 2000 a group of scientists published a special report in the peer reviewed Journal of American Veterinary Medicine, entitled “Breeds of dogs involved in fatal human attacks in the United States between 1979 and 1998.” The report states:
Under “Results,” the report continues:
I recommend clicking on the link and viewing tables 1 and 2. Pit bull types and Rottweilers, whether purebred or mixed, account for a disproportionate number of human DBRF. The report does discuss limitations on the data, but states:
A lot of people on this forum have expressed dismay (even anger) at the suggestion that certain breeds of dogs are more inherently dangerous than others. I really don’t understand that reaction. Dogs were bred with specific purposes in mind. Dogs that displayed the desired characteristics were bred, same was done for their pups, etc. Thus we have retrievers, herders, gazehounds, scent hounds, bulldogs, pit bulls, etc. I don’t think it should come as any particular surprise that certain breeds would be more prone to violence. This isn’t a blanket condemnation of all Rottweilers or pit bull types. This isn’t a proposition to cull their breeds off the face of the planet. But they are more likely to harm and kill humans. That’s what the stats say. If anyone can produce a scientific rebuttal to the above report, I’d love to see it.[/quote]
I like the way you say scientific rebuttal. That is a good sentence, as most people when talking about dogs and certain dog breeds understandably tend to get very emotional and science goes out the window.
As for your post, I’ll look into those stats more closely later as I have a very good background in stats.
However you might be surprised that I tend to agree with you. As many know I am a great lover of bull and terrier dogs “pit dogs”. What you say about breeds being bred to do certain things so have a great potential to be good at those things, and often “wish” to do those things is of course true. Lurchers catch hares, gray hounds for running, blood hounds for tracking, fox hounds for hunting. Any one involved in the professional breeding of livestock or agricultural crops (as I once was) knows that this is a non brainer. Anyone that says other wise is very misguided or has a bad grasp of genetics and biology. Rottweilers were bred for guarding. Whether it was for guarding sheep or houses or whatever the were principally guarding dogs. Guarding dogs are selected for their ability to guard and are not bred to be over friendly towards humans. Therefore it is of course no surprise that Rottweilers are involved in many attacks in back yards when looked after by irresponsible owners.
Now onto “pitbull” types. I am too lazy to write too much on this but know a lot more than I can write. Basically (oversimplified) the theory many pet pitbull owners have is this.
(1) Pitbulls were bred to fight or bait animals and not people. So will not show any out of the ordinary aggression to people but may do to other dogs, cats, horses etc
(2) In the past when pitbulls were used in the “pit” they fought in close proximity to their owner. Therefore any dogs that attacked or turned on their handlers in the pit were culled. Therefore they were selected for dog on dog aggression and were de-selected for human aggression.
There are a few problems with this theory. Most pet pit bull owners presume number two was correct. That human aggressive dogs were put to sleep. However this is generally inaccurate (although sometimes true by a few of the so called ‘old timers”). Yes pit bulls were not bred for human aggression, however they were also generally not de-selected against it. Expensive champion dogs that were manny (man biters) were not usually put down, despite the myth that they were. Most dogs that win dog fights are kept and fed and looked after regardless of any man biting potential as they are worth lots of money. Any one who disputes it can just look to the “chinaman” line of pit bulls (google it). The Chinaman line was and probably still is the most successful and most common pitbull lines of dogs in existence. The original dog “Chinaman” was known as a Man biter and an extremely dangerous dog that sometimes tried to attack spectators. The Chinaman genes still exist in a large proportion of pit bulls in existence today (tight breeding).
In addition to this pit bulls as you know are now often being kept as pets by “ordinary” people. What are the selection pressures on these pets to maintain aggression toward animals and not people. Well they are pets so there is no selection pressure. Also gangsters and drug dealers are now keeping these dogs as body guards and are only breeding the most man aggressive ones they can find (which nullifies point 1). The times when the pit bull was bred and kept only by the “dog fighter” have gone. There are now different selection pressures for “man” aggression (only breeding human aggressive dogs). Couple this with the champion pit bulls unbeatable trait of “never surrender” (gameness) we are in for a lot worse to come, unfortunately in Taiwan! Singapore and Hong Kong already have a pit bull ban I’m sure a tragedy in Taiwan is just waiting to happen.
Incidentally pit bulls are and were also used for bear and bull baiting. I’m not sure a stray pit bull would be anymore friendly to a human than a bear.
So yes Mr Gao I generally agree with your summing up on those stats! Also ask yourself why the conformation version of the pit bull “American staffordshire bull terrier” is not as common as the pit bull ? Well they have had most of the “gameness” and “aggression” bred out of them years and years ago. Not so exciting a dog to have for the gangster and drug dealer as a pit bull. They are also not a great punk accessory item.
Interestingly the Presa canirio (canary island dog) is making fast inroads against pit bulls both as guard dogs and larger style fighting dogs. Try fighting one of those beasts off in the youth park when they get to Taiwan in a couple of years!
Breed specific legislation is not effective because there is always another breed that will replace the latest 'devil dog". I remember when it used to be German sheppards years ago. Next will be the presa no doubt. The only way to legislate against breeds is to go the German route, banning all dogs of certain sizes. Personally however i don’t want to live in a country like that. So I am against BSL but also against some of the bullshit breed supporters spout about their breed being the nicest and friendliest blah blah blah while completely ignoring the genetic potential (yes environment also plays a big part) of the breed to their later sorrow.
Facing the facts is the best way to prevent tragedies from happening.

