From: “Mary Jane Butters” maryjane@maryjanesfarm.org Add to Address Book
To: “This Sender” ioot@yahoo.com
Subject: Re: Made in Taiwan
Date: Tue, 18 Nov 2003 07:03:46 -0800
Please refer to “Taiwan Exchange” on our website on the main splash page, www.maryjanesfarm.org. Also I’m attaching below a letter I received last night from someone who read the “Taiwan Exchange” on my website. Thank you for your comments and for taking the time to care. This is an important issue for EVERY country, including the U.S. It appears there is more than meets the eye. Mary Jane
Mary Jane,
You may not be as far off the mark as you thought. I did a quick Internet
search on “Child Labor Taiwan” and I wish I could report that all is rosy
in Taiwan.
Overall, it appears that Taiwan has some good child labor and
non-exploitation laws. However, good does not mean perfect. According to
various child labor watchdog sources, there is evidence of Indonesian child
labor imported into Taiwan for domestic and farm work. Taiwan-owned
factories exploit thousands of Chinese children just across the water in
the Fujian region of China. Also, an American shoe company is alleged to
have used Taiwan as cover to hide use of child labor in Indonesia. All of
this information is readily available on the Internet.
So perhaps the angry tone in some of these e-mails is misplaced. As a
person who buys and consumes your products, I can vouch for the value and
quality of your food. My wife visited your farm and she reports that your
farm is an example of labor done right. I thought you and your readers might
be interested in more than one side of the story.
Thank you,
D
PS - As a businessperson, I realize it may not be in your interests to print this. As
a customer who can’t find quality dried food anywhere else, it is in my interests that
you remain a profitable viable business. So my request is that you relegate this
Taiwan Exchange page to a minor corner of your site along with its harsh rhetoric.
As you can see below, there is plenty of child exploitation to go around, even for
Taiwan.
Here is the proof…
Child Workers in Asia
cwa.tnet.co.th/about_child_l … _labor.htm
There are reports now children from Indonesia brought to Singapore,
Malaysia, and Taiwan for domestic and farm work, or even for work in small
factories.
CHILD LABOR IN CHINA
(Change HKCIC- June 1996)
citinv.it/associazioni/CNMS/ … ldlab.html
Many workers, including child workers, in China are forced to work in very
dangerous (sic) conditions.
(snip)
It was reported in January, 1996 that more than 70,000 (230,000 reported by
Ming Pao and Agence France Presse) women working in mostly Taiwan owned shoe
factories in southeastern Fujian could have been exposed to benzene
poisoning 5 times the legal maximum (Ming Pao claims 10 times).
The Tragedy of Child Labor
The following is an edited version of the article originally published in
the Summer 1996 issue of Working People.
(according to the author of the web page)
geocities.com/Athens/Acropol … People.htm
When Nike was recently accused of having Michael Jordans line of sneakers
made by 11-year olds in Indonesia at 14 cents an hour, Nike officials
pointed to the fact that the sneakers carry the label “Made in Taiwan.”
That label, however, only indicates that the final assembly (sic) was done
in Taiwan. It does not mean, however, that no portion of the sneaker line
is made in Indonesia.
----- Original Message -----
From: This Sender
To: maryjane@maryjanesfarm.org
Sent: Monday, November 17, 2003 10:02 PM
Subject: Made in Taiwan
To: maryjane@maryjanesfarm.org
Subject: Made in Taiwan
deseretnews.com/dn/view/0%2C1249 … %2C00.html
Dear Mary Jane,
In a recent AP article I read an unfortunate quote by you
complaining about buying things “made by a child in Taiwan.” As a
resident in Taiwan, there is no child labor problem here at all. I would
invite you to learn more about the subject before making further
embarassing comments like this. I hope that you have the opportunity to
visit this country some time to learn more about it.
<< ioot@yahoo.com ICQ: 149136361 Taipei, Taiwan >>