Personal Space in Taiwan

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Personal_space

When I first got back to Taiwan from Canada a couple months ago… I was really annoyed by the difference in concept of personal space here.

As you can see by this depiction, (upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/c … _Space.svg) Taiwanese people regularly invade what is regarded in the West as Personal Space… and many-a-time also invade what would be Intimate Space.

Sometimes, it’s kind of arousing to have an attractive person invade your Intimate Space as oft many attractive Taiwanese do… but at other times, I don’t want the old man behind me in line at 7-11 invading my ass space with his crotch (I live in Yonghe, just to remind you…)!

It seems that in Taiwan, the labels for the circles go down to the next smallest circle… and the only Intimate Space you’re left with is skin-to-skin contact.

Also, I’m pretty sure that many Westerners misconstrue the difference in personal space as flirting or some kind of sexual interest…

Your thoughts? Like it? Hate it? Got used to it like me?

Here in cAlif, im amused that people feel threatened by your presence when you are within ,sometimes , fifty feet of them. When one person is walking to his/her car and approaches another person within fifty feet of him/her, its obligatory to say “hi” to acknowledge each other.

In Taiwan they can be sandwhiched right up to you in a crowded bus and they still will NOT say hi.

Taiwanese will walk right past each other on a crowded footpath and not say hi, but Americans will say hi soon as they come within fifty feet of each other it seems, less if theres a curve in the path.

Its a matter of personal space perception. In a country with lots of space, we tend to project our personal space. Whereas in Taiwan, its a dense pack society. Taiwanese do not feel they are invading YOUR personal space even if they are 3 inches away from you in as crowded space and even if they are one foot away from you in an otherwise fairly uncrowded space.

The concept of personal space is a lot different. They will only say dway bu chee if they actually RUN into you on the street (and then only maybe).

But Americans are NOT saying Hi because they are friendly. They are saying HI because they feel threatened and want to see if you are a friend or foe.

Taiwanese dont feel threatened by other people while walking in Taiwan and therefore do not feel the need to cross check someone they come across as friend or foe.

Regarding pleasant company on crowded buses. I do not leave things to chance. I will stand next to pretty ladies rather then men (old or young) because I know how tightly pressed you could be.

YOu can practically be slow dancing on those buses. Choose your partners :slight_smile:

Nowadays I dont think TW buses/ MRT get THAT crowded anymore. Which is generally a very good thing. However, sometimes one can miss the “close fellowship”.

If nothing else, it makes you feel more human.

I can deal with the lack of personal space in public…I don’t like it and the lack of it is probably a reason I don’t enjoy public excursions to the city, but I can deal with it.

What I consider an even greater violation of my personal space is the noise pollution. I go to work then on the weekend I want some peace and quiet in my own home. Instead I get random firecrackers going off at all hours, goddamn loudspeaker trucks, and where I live we have these town crier speakers where some old leatherlungs makes announcements once a week.

I don’t understand why Taiwanese put up with this crap…many of them work longer hours than I do, at worse jobs…but if you can’t relax out in public, and can’t do so in your own home, that ain’t good for the state of mental health. If I had a kid or sleeping problems I’d probably lose my shit with the constant noise barrage…and it’s always on the weekend.

I think most are hard of hearing from all the constant noise 24/7.

I remember when I first came here it was common to still use public telephones. If I wanted to use a phone, I would wait a respectful distance from the person on the phone only to lose my place when he finished as no one thought I was waiting, and so jumped in.

But other than that though it’s never bothered me. Italians bother me because they like to talk too close. Taiwanese talk at a comfortable distance though they will stand or move around you at a much closer radius than in Canada. However, there is no awkwardness in this (ie, they don’t project discomfort) so I don’t feel it either.

People walking super slow, now that bugs me, though like most things here, if you just accept the local ways it’s pretty easy going.

[quote=“tommy525”]Here in cAlif, im amused that people feel threatened by your presence when you are within ,sometimes , fifty feet of them. When one person is walking to his/her car and approaches another person within fifty feet of him/her, its obligatory to say “hi” to acknowledge each other.

In Taiwan they can be sandwhiched right up to you in a crowded bus and they still will NOT say hi.

Taiwanese will walk right past each other on a crowded footpath and not say hi, but Americans will say hi soon as they come within fifty feet of each other it seems, less if theres a curve in the path.

Its a matter of personal space perception. In a country with lots of space, we tend to project our personal space. Whereas in Taiwan, its a dense pack society. Taiwanese do not feel they are invading YOUR personal space even if they are 3 inches away from you in as crowded space and even if they are one foot away from you in an otherwise fairly uncrowded space.

The concept of personal space is a lot different. They will only say dway bu chee if they actually RUN into you on the street (and then only maybe).

But Americans are NOT saying Hi because they are friendly. They are saying HI because they feel threatened and want to see if you are a friend or foe.

Taiwanese dont feel threatened by other people while walking in Taiwan and therefore do not feel the need to cross check someone they come across as friend or foe.

Regarding pleasant company on crowded buses. I do not leave things to chance. I will stand next to pretty ladies rather then men (old or young) because I know how tightly pressed you could be.

YOu can practically be slow dancing on those buses. Choose your partners :slight_smile:

Nowadays I don’t think TW buses/ MRT get THAT crowded anymore. Which is generally a very good thing. However, sometimes one can miss the “close fellowship”.

If nothing else, it makes you feel more human.[/quote]

Are you sure people are saying hi because they feel threatened?! In Canada, not everyone says hi… usually just old people… and no, it’s not from 50 feet away… more like 10 feet.

Yeah… I don’t want to be a pervert by purposely standing next to the most attractive female… hahaha… but, well, I suppose one might as well! It’s great when an attractive member of the opposite sex chooses you, though. That means that you are attractive… rather than a pervert!

[quote=“mups”]I can deal with the lack of personal space in public…I don’t like it and the lack of it is probably a reason I don’t enjoy public excursions to the city, but I can deal with it.

What I consider an even greater violation of my personal space is the noise pollution. I go to work then on the weekend I want some peace and quiet in my own home. Instead I get random firecrackers going off at all hours, goddamn loudspeaker trucks, and where I live we have these town crier speakers where some old leatherlungs makes announcements once a week.

I don’t understand why Taiwanese put up with this crap…many of them work longer hours than I do, at worse jobs…but if you can’t relax out in public, and can’t do so in your own home, that ain’t good for the state of mental health. If I had a kid or sleeping problems I’d probably lose my shit with the constant noise barrage…and it’s always on the weekend.[/quote]

Yes, this is the thing I hate the most about Taiwan, too. At least ugly/dirty/messy can be ignored when you are at home… or you can avoid brushing up on old men and young women by staying away from crowded places…

Are you also a connoisseur of “The Many Sounds of Jackhammer”? Or, am only I a connoisseur, because I live in a middle-class and lower area?

What I wonder is… what is the explanation for not giving a crap about noise? WHAT IS THE EXPLANATION!!! Is it rapid economic development?

Hahaha… well, maybe they’re just really good at ignoring sound? Like, I’ve seen people almost get run over by ambulances, because they didn’t notice it coming down the road. An AMBULANCE with lights blaring and sirens… that are… as loud as the garbage truck. LOL. But yeah, almost killed by the ambulance. She looks up and, “Whoa! Where’d this ambulance come from?!”

[quote=“Mucha Man”]I remember when I first came here it was common to still use public telephones. If I wanted to use a phone, I would wait a respectful distance from the person on the phone only to lose my place when he finished as no one thought I was waiting, and so jumped in.

But other than that though it’s never bothered me. Italians bother me because they like to talk too close. Taiwanese talk at a comfortable distance though they will stand or move around you at a much closer radius than in Canada. However, there is no awkwardness in this (ie, they don’t project discomfort) so I don’t feel it either.

People walking super slow, now that bugs me, though like most things here, if you just accept the local ways it’s pretty easy going.[/quote]

Hahaha… that’s exactly what happens to me at the post office. But, I always say, “Hey! You cut in line.” Then, the person profusely apologizes and gets behind me.

About discomfort… yeah… it’s true. Like, I can stand really close to someone and they won’t care (if there’s a legitimate reason, of course).

But, what about the pushing and shoving? It doesn’t happen too often, but every now and then, someone will really push (usually old ladies)… or maybe they push by accident? I push back in the same manner (oops! accident!), and nobody ever says anything.

I like to fully extend my arm (in a Heisman like pose) and spin around slowly while scraming “gimme space, I can’t breathe here, I need space!”

works like a charm!

[quote=“Deuce Dropper”]I like to fully extend my arm (in a Heisman like pose) and spin around slowly while scraming “gimme space, I can’t breathe here, I need space!”

works like a charm![/quote]

You dont understand Taiwanese culture bro. The magic trick is to laugh softly to yourself a few times. This is a SURE sign to Taiwanese that you are looney and they will give you birth…uh i mean berth.

p.s. on a crowded taipei bus…sure its nice when a pretty girl picks you to stand next to, especially in a slow dance position, but why leave things to chance? Make your own luck and get in front of a cutie. YOu have to squeeze somebody, why not pick your partner?

p.p.s Americans are often ARMED, so YES, they DO want affirmation you are friend before they will get closer to you. Thats why a Hi works to defuse the situ (actually its a false security tho).

A baddie could say HI to you then when you get in striking distance lash out at you.

:roflmao: Personal space? In Taiwan? :ponder:

I think you got it wrong tommy, saying hi is just a friendly gesture. It’s like the way Americans say Sir a lot, I always liked that. In my country even car drivers acknowledge each other in the countryside and we don’t blacken out our windows to hide away, it’s a neighborly thing. You see unlike Taiwan western countries still have neighborhoods where you may actually know your neighbor!

Out in the Australian wheatbelt it’s about thirty meters, which is getting pretty close to optimal shotgun range come to think of it. :ponder:

I don’t mind the reduced personal space in Taiwan because everyone ignores you anyway. I’m often in crowed buses or trains yet I very rarely see any squabbling.

If you think Taiwan is bad, try India.

i dont think this is a regional/country thing, it is a city/countryside thing. even here in taiwan, the countryside EVERYONE knows EVERYONE and when they last shit and what they are cooking for dinner. it drives me up the wall as everyone here knows me by name, and where im going! i am a very private person so it bothers me, but i dont think its anything wrong with the people here, i like the idea of it actually (just not for me). this is the biggest reason why we moved to a house that is not connected to another house. we have abandoned farm breeding snakes on one side and a house with farm on the other. behinds is all farm and in front is a road. so if i want to play music or watch tv loud have people over etc i dont need to worry. neighbours dont like the dog? they can stuff it now cause the house isnt connected. i truly dont understand how people get alone in condos/apartments here (or anywhere). not only do you have people on the side but also above/below many times. crikey, fuck that.

If you live here (well at least in CAlif) for any length of time you will discover a few things:

  1. Friendly Americans are usually found OUTSIDE of the USA.
  2. Americans here are wary of each other and think ill of you until you prove them wrong.
  3. And they are not wrong to feel that way because we have a LOT of kooks around.
  4. Sorry to burst your bubble but the HI given is not really out of friendliness, it is saying " I see you and Im a watchin You". Americans are NOT really friendly people on the whole. Strangely enough New Yorkers are much friendlier on the whole then SAn Franciscans. And you know what they say bout New Yorkers?

[quote=“tommy525”]If you live here (well at least in CAlif) for any length of time you will discover a few things:

  1. Friendly Americans are usually found OUTSIDE of the USA.
  2. Americans here are wary of each other and think ill of you until you prove them wrong.
  3. And they are not wrong to feel that way because we have a LOT of kooks around.
  4. Sorry to burst your bubble but the HI given is not really out of friendliness, it is saying " I see you and Im a watchin You". Americans are NOT really friendly people on the whole. Strangely enough New Yorkers are much friendlier on the whole then SAn Franciscans. And you know what they say bout New Yorkers?[/quote]

They are just contemplating how they are planning to eat you you, the fat bastards, and thinking makes their heads hurt.

It’s just a matter of fact. Densely populated areas. It’s not like anyone can help it. So after a while (say 50 years for arguments sake) people are used to having to concede personal space. If you have grown up with it, it’s just normal and not something that you would readily question.

Same goes for noise pollution. I agree with others though noise pollution is far worse.

Tommy, I’m never sure if you’re a suave, funny charmer or the creepy old guy.

As for personal space, I had one incident where I was standing at the side of an ‘entrance’ with a metre between me and the other edge. Some asshole walked in less that 20cm away from me, making me go O.O;;;; WTF?! …and then he walked out the same way. I really didn’t think he was gonna do it again going out, or I’d’ve tripped him up.

[quote=“tsukinodeynatsu”][quote=“tommy525”]
p.s. on a crowded taipei bus…sure its nice when a pretty girl picks you to stand next to, especially in a slow dance position, but why leave things to chance? Make your own luck and get in front of a cutie. YOu have to squeeze somebody, why not pick your partner?
[/quote]

Tommy, I’m never sure if you’re a suave, funny charmer or the creepy old guy.

As for personal space, I had one incident where I was standing at the side of an ‘entrance’ with a metre between me and the other edge. Some asshole walked in less that 20cm away from me, making me go O.O;;;; WTF?! …and then he walked out the same way. I really didn’t think he was gonna do it again going out, or I’d’ve tripped him up.[/quote]

You just dont understand taiwanese culture :smiley:

[quote=“tommy525”]If you live here (well at least in CAlif) for any length of time you will discover a few things:

  1. Friendly Americans are usually found OUTSIDE of the USA.
  2. Americans here are wary of each other and think ill of you until you prove them wrong.
  3. And they are not wrong to feel that way because we have a LOT of kooks around.
  4. Sorry to burst your bubble but the HI given is not really out of friendliness, it is saying " I see you and Im a watchin You". Americans are NOT really friendly people on the whole. Strangely enough New Yorkers are much friendlier on the whole then SAn Franciscans. And you know what they say bout New Yorkers?[/quote]
    Matter of perception I guess. I’m from the Bay Area and I think the friendliness level is perfect. I’ll never forget the first time I went back to Cali after living in Taiwan. I was walking on a sidewalk and passed someone. We glanced up from a good distance away, met eyes, looked away. Glanced again just as we were about to pass each other, gave a half-smile. Looked away when we were actually passing.
    And I remember just feeling “YES! You did that exactly PERFECT! That is how strangers are supposed to behave when they pass each other in close proximity!”
    My reaction surprised me because I wasn’t aware that Taiwan’s ‘passing in close proximity’ laws bugged me. Perhaps it’s just that everyone feels they have to acknowledge my presence here.
    But I noticed my personal space bubble has collapsed a bit- I def get closer to strangers than i used to.
    The thing that gets me here is when I get ‘walking rage’. People just don’t move right and it drives me up the fucking wall!

I think theres less genuine friendliness among strangers here in the bay area then in TAiwan. I dont mean outward appearance friendliness which bay area denizens are good at. The passing each other on the street, the quick smile , the “hi”. But its all a carefully orchestrated falseness.

Even when you do manage to strike up a conversation in a cafe, which in itself is prettty rare. It really doesnt ever lead anywhere. Its much more the , dont ask me who I am and I wont ask you who you are thing.

Whereas on Taiwan if a conversation is struck up, its likely to lead to an exchange of telephone numbers and a start of a possible friendship.

Your mileage may vary of course. I can only speak with some authority for myself and my own personal experiences.

IN Taiwan strangers do not acknowledge your presence in passing, or say hi or even nod and they do not smile at you. Even if they stare at you.

But its genuine , not fake or forced by social behavior.