Rooftop:
Find all the quotes where I have not referred specifically to government policies of France. Traveller used to berate me all the time for using German or French in my writings but it is so obvious that we are talking about national policies here that I cannot believe that this is really an issue. Then, why are you not also equally outraged when blanket statements about “Americans” are made?
Second, if there are so many major accomplishments from Arab and Muslim culture then surely you could rattle off that list right here and right now. Let’s say the top 50 contributions? Why not just put them down right here and right now since there are so many.
Also, do let us know when and where and how the Muslim world was tolerant during the Middle Ages. I would love to hear this.
I am not saying NO contributions but I am ASKING what those major and important contributions are. Please fill me in.
Third, I find your outrage agaisnt prejudice and discrimination somewhat lopsided. You find that it is acceptable to caricature Condi Rice in the worst sort of way but cannot find one statement where I have ever said anything racist against Blacks. So you are inferring that I am a racist for supporing Condi Rice who is black and that makes sense how exactly?
Fourth, I find it interesting that those of us who have been to the Middle East are able to discuss this topic with a fair amount of logic and reasoning while you just attack anyone for supposed racist statements or inflammatory statements against Arabs and Islam. Do you know any Arabs or Muslims? Have you ever been to the Middle East? Have you ever even studied it? Do you have any idea about the present political and economic as well as social and cultural factors that are present there? I doubt it very much. I do.
Fifth, you keep setting up these strawmen and no one is buying it.
For the record, I am not against France or the French, I am against the policies of Jacques Chirac and Dominique de Villepin.
I am not against Islam per se, but I think that it is very important that if we are to take this as a religion of “peace” then moderates in the religion will have to start standing up to be heard. They must condemn the violence and terrorism that are carried out in its name by adherents of the religion and must stop supporting such efforts financially or tacitly. I do not think that it is racist to point out that Arab societies are not democratic nor do they respect human rights. If these are important issues, we must address them and call these societies and their leaders to account. We must do what we can to help these societies develop those institutions or they will fall back in terms of human development even further. Unless of course, you do not care and find this an unimportant goal.
Arabs and Muslims can handle respect for human righst, they can be tolerant, they can have working democracies. Just as we had to defeat Fascist forces in Germany, Japan and Italy to bring Europe into the enlightened modern world, just as we had to fight communists in the Soviet empire, China, and Latin America and Africa so too can we defeat the Islamofascist forces of intolerance who preach hate and intolerance.
Being intolerant of the intolerant and hating those that hate is not incompatible with Western enlightenment any more than it is for police to hate crime and judges to hate infractions of the law. Get real.