Back in the ol country, which has very open immigration and tourist policies, this kind of thing is encouraged as well as many other cultural exchange, student exchange and whatever thing brings people from abroad. Even though we are a tourist trap with very good reputation, it is important to bring people from far away places in the world, like Japan and Norway and many others, who come on these programs to have a look and may stay or may go, but with a better understanding of the country, good memories and hopefully the desire to return or tell others to come.
Obviously, these people do not work at McDs but most take to tourist related industries where their language skills will be better utilized -tourism being the big thing in the ol country. Actually, the pilot program of this WH was a coffee shop in Taichung or Nantou or somewhere in Central Taiwan if memory serves me right. In Taiwan, I could see them developing social platforms for enterprises, office communication mater if their Chinese is good enough. Plenty of other opportunities to help market Taiwan products. Service industry wise an extra hand at overcrowded hotels and hostels or even transportation hubs and exhibition centers comes to mind. Most people would have some interest in culture and arts, why not have them working in the culture parks? There is already a very interesting foreign resident artist program in place.
Opportunities are not the issue, me thinks. The program has its rules regarding work permits. The issue is, as said, the focus being less on money making, in spite of whatever it is said. For people in the ol country, going to Europe as an au pair is an opportunity to learn a language with lesser costs for a longer time. It is not working simply as a maid and certainly not affordable to people working as maids in the ol country -and may I point out, no visa is required for us in the Schegen area. You could say “oh, working in child care is demeaning, blablabla”, like picking apples in NZ or Auz could be constructed. It is an opportunity. You want to make lots of dough, find a full time job.
Many Taiwanese students are flocking to WH abroad because of the dough, because here you get offered 20K with a masters degree, while picking apples you get 40K if you are frugal. There have been many news reports on TV regarding Taiwanese students living conditions in Auz nd NZ, very, very frugal, and yes, the occasional victims of cheating bosses and stuff. But that happens everywhere, even in one’s own country. The money factor is stressed in every news report I see, so I believe this is more important for Taiwanese students than for students from abroad in Taiwan, who must already know they cannot make a fortune here unless working full time as foreigners. And if they wanted to work in service industry in Taiwan, they would. But you can ask any laoban here how hard it is to find and hire and keep help these days. Kids cannot be bothered. OTOH, you have the guys with PhDs opening donut and chicken pie shops, because having a food stand pays better.
For one of my ex Taiwanese roomies, going to NZ was a way to hide her pregnancy from her family and keep the kid -she was trying to loop in the guy, -Taiwanese BTW- but working with farm animals 4 months pregnant must not have been pleasant.