Argument about child-education

Ok, here is the situation, I try to make it short:
Me foreigner married to tw wife. Expecting our first baby. Original idea was, that I will be at home, take care on our baby.
Due to the fact that english isn’t my first language, it’s not that easy to find a full-time job for myself. I do mostly private tutoring, thus making around 10.000 NT$ net cash. Wife is doing very well moneywise, so we don’t suffer financial-wise.
This situation is fine for my wife (but not for me as I dislike to be dependant on her), so I don’t need any advice nor “bad comments” about this situation.

I wish to find a fulltime job (not easy where I live in Taiwan), and I don’t use my situation (etc. lack of fluent chinese) as an excuse for not having a better job.
If having one, I have no problem at all to use my salary to pay off my mother-in-law, so she can quitt her currently very exhausting, not well paid job.
Giving mother-in law my current salary and wife topping the sum up, won’t unfortunately work-out …

Unfortunately I haven’t found one yet, so my wife came out with an idea, which (although having some positive things as well) is unacceptable for me.
To be precise:
A good friend of my wife is also pregnant (one month ahead), and she and her husband definately want to continue her normal work-life. Their parents are (for some not important reasons) unavailable to take care their own child, thus they are looking for a fulltime babysitter. They are worried an unknown babysitter, so my wife had the idea, that her mother could do this job. Meaning, my mother (60 years old) would get the payment from my wife’s friend.

So far so good (and in fact none of my business after all).
As my wife got unregular working times including common overtime and me mostly tutoring in the evening, it looks like we sometimes have noone to take care our baby. This truly could and will be a problem in the future. Unfortunately we don’t have anyone else family alike, who could step-in in such situations.

Therefor wife got the idea, that mother in-law take care the “customers” baby at OUR place (I live alone with my wife). Meaning 2 babies, mother in-law and myself. This would fit any maybe occuring problems, in case I have to go out for my tutoring, but the price would be a COMPLETE LOSS of (at least) my privacy.

I have a very good relationchip with my mother in-law. In fact I offered here many times to live with us together, which she is always rejecting. Again, I fully trust her and have no problem at all to give her the daytime care, IF I would make enouhg money to pay her. In such case, she would go back to her home once either my wife or me would be home.

But I seriously doubt it how this kind of situation would work:

Although none of my business, but I am asking myself, what kind of parents my wife’s friend and her husband are. Just contiueing her life like usual, give the baby to a (more or less) stranger and take it back whenever they want. Like: After work, we wanna see movie, can pick her/him up later …

2a)
Nothing against my mother in-law, but how can she take care a (foreign-to-her) baby and in the meantime watching her grandchild playing with me ?

2b)
It will be our first child. Of course we feel excited about it. I (at least) feel anxious too, as I really don’t know what challenge is waiting for me. I think it is natural and very good to have someone around you with baby-experience. But I fear, that I will be watched and controlled and beeing corrected by her. Sometimes with a reason, but I read stories in here, that in many cases the logic of education is culture-alike different in many ways …

What I am supposing to do? Playing with the other baby as well? Don’t the other baby (maybe) think, I could be his/her father, in case I have a lot of contact with her/him ?

What about legal problems, in case something may happen to the other child ?

Why on earth my mother in-law doesn’t go to either her own place (or even better the place where my wife’s friend is living) in in case of a timing-problem I just go there to “drop off” (sorry bad verb) my baby ?

I am a huge fan of babies/children groups. That young families are organizing meetings, each other at different places, for a few hours. Playing, exchanging information, this way also develope friendchips.
BUT I really get the impression our home (an appartment, not a toutian) will turn into a (long-time) kindergarden doing this way. Also I fear that my mother in-law will slighty take over the control of my child. I feel I am just used as the milk-donater and as beeing in Taiwan the things has to turn out the taiwanese way.

Based on your experience, would it be a good idea, if babies would be together already from the beginning ? Just like twins ?

And in case this information is important to you, the house in 90% paid by my wife, so it is honestly her place and therefore her right to decide what’s going on.

PLEASE HELP, LEAVE YOUR COMMENTS - thank you very much for these.
Once again, I do see here some advantages. It makes me sad, that my wife doesn’t want to respect my point, which definately mostly is the lack of privacy. This she can’t imagine, because she is out for work while we are all at home.

I tried one to talk with my wife, but it seems she has already made up her mind. Pretty difficult to let her hear my concerns, which I think are very reasonable.

Hi! Welcome to f.com and hope you get some solid advice. I completely disagree with the above statement. Your house may have been financed by your wife, but the two of you make a home. The one who stays home and takes care of the kids, decides what is the most comfortable way in which they can care for the baby and give the bay their best self. If you feel uncomfortable having another child at home, then that’s the way it should be.

I have to admit that I only read the first 20% of your post.

However, the first words that came into my mind were: ‘teach kindy.’

@ tomthorne

what an arrogant and stupid answer is that …
I am very aware of my english ability and I have never said I am teaching english here.
There are tons of other things for tutoring, but in your narrow mind these possibilities seems not to exist …

Looking forward for HELPFUL opinions and suggestions

I think tomhorne wasn’t disrespecting your English. Kindy jobs can be quite easy to get for non native speakers. I myself have worked with French guys teaching in an English kindy. I also worked with a Dutch guy at the same school and know another German guy working at another kindy. Don’t be too quick to presume that you won’t get a job! sometimes all a kindy is looking for is someone with their own arc.
As regards your problem I would suggest trying it out for a while but be sure it’s clear that it’s a trial! And don’t think too badly of the other parents sometimes people here have no choice but to go back to work.

Regarding other couple:
I don’t want to go too much into the details, but believe me, her friend and her husband have both a very high income (7 figure/each/yearly).

Thank you for your suggestion with the trial version. But it is difficult, as mother in-law definately has to quitt her job for doing this.
And I doubt, if a normal weekend, or a 10 day period (her vacation) would be time enough as a trial-period. However I agree, it is indeed
at least worth a try.

Regarding kindergarden:
Not the first time I hear non-native speakeres working in such places. I tried it before, and I was always front-door rejected. Isn’t there a law
preventing foreigners working in such places if you don’t have a license for that ? I admit I haven’t tried that again for a longer time, but I agree,
it’s time then to apply again - thank you for the advice

Talked to a tw friend, he told me, that any babysitter in TW needs a license to do so. But nobody seems to care about this. He also says my wife and me
would be responsible for anything might happening, as the place of anf possible accidents would be our (her) house.
They are friends, but who knows how this friendchip may turn out, just in case. Yes, maybe I am super-careful about this, but on contrary not even
considering the legal-justice thing will be careless too, wouldn’t be ?

Agreed, TomThorne’s suggestion isn’t a bad one, I’ve met several non-native kindy teachers, and your English seems proficient enough to teach Kindy. That would be at least 30 thou a month that you could add to your income for a couple of hours of work in the morning. That is, if you’re uncomfortable with your wife being the bread-winner.
As far as your mother-in-law being in your home, I’m with you all the way- that would feel intrusive and it could have a negative effect on your relationship with her. Be polite about it but stick to your guns and insist she spends time at her own house.
Good luck.

Ok I didn’t realize the legal issue was so serious. Taking that into consideration I would absolutely say no and explain to your wife that you are looking out for her and your baby when saying no as if something did happen you could find yourselves in a very messy situation. Your mum-inlaw also needs to understand the risk she’s taking. I have two kids and if anything happened to them friendship goes out the window.

[quote]He also says my wife and me
would be responsible for anything might happening, as the place of anf possible accidents would be our (her) house.
They are friends, but who knows how this friendchip may turn out, just in case. Yes, maybe I am super-careful about this[/quote]
Your friend is right. You WOULD be responsible for any accidents when the child is in your care. And, without a caregiver license, you will NOT be able to get insurance coverage against that possibility.
And “they are friends.” You’re not being “super-careful” I don’t think. Friends can have a way of suddenly becoming enemies where money – ie financial compensation for something that happened to their kid while in your care – is concerned. Think about worst-case scenario: You are washing their baby and you accidentally drop it on its head. Don’t laugh – it HAPPENS! Their child gets brain damage as a result and requires life-long 24-hour care. Who do you think will pay for that? Yup. YOU and your wife.
IMO, your wife is looking only at what she considers to be the “most convenient” solution. It sounds like a very risky deal, to me. Time to put your foot down.