Being bullied then dismissed on invalid grounds

Sorry, this may be a bit long.

  1. Moving to Douliu
    I got a job offer at a small cram school in Douliu, so I moved from Tainan to start working. It wasn’t easy having three kids under six, but we made it work because the school seemed promising, and we were looking for a place with more space and a slower lifestyle.

  2. Working 22–25 Hours Plus Camp Hours
    I began working on January 15th. I was not given time to observe classes, nor was I provided with a trial period. Shortly before my start date, the boss sent me a LINE message informing me about a winter camp that would be held the week after I started. I was asked to prepare lesson plans for three hours a day (9:00 AM–12:10 PM) for 10 days while still teaching well over 22 hours of regular classes. I wasn’t given an exact deadline for the camp lesson plans. Initially, the boss told me to submit them to her, but later, she asked me to submit them to the other foreign teacher, which I did before the camp began.

  3. Teaching at Camp Plus Regular Classes
    There were 20 students in the camp class, all packed into a small classroom. When I asked to take them outside for activities, I was told I could only use the balcony area outside the building—next to a busy road with no gates.

I quickly realized within the first few days that none of my planned lessons would work under these circumstances. There was barely any space. I was told that if I bought materials, I should submit receipts. So, I spent about $1,200 on ingredients to make cookies with the students. However, I was later told that my purchase exceeded the budget for the entire camp.

  1. Being Late to Class
    I did my best to keep up with both camp lessons and preparing lesson plans for 3–5 daily classes, each using 3–5 textbooks. I barely slept or ate. A couple of times, I was late to class because I had to use the slow printer in the building. Only once was I five minutes late to the camp class because I was finishing a sandwich after pulling an all-nighter preparing lessons. I know being late was wrong, but no one addressed it with me directly either.

  2. Lesson Plans
    The boss asked me to submit lesson plans ahead of class by sending her a picture. Later, the secretary also started asking for the plans and taking pictures of them. However, on several occasions, I was still writing them when she asked. I always completed them before the lesson.

Then, in the third week, the boss asked me to email her the lesson plans instead. I went to the school’s Google page and sent them to the email listed there. I also informed the local teacher at the front desk that I had done so.

  1. Reprimands & Gifts

First Reprimand (Friday, 2/7)
In the first two weeks, the boss kept offering me second-hand items, like old furniture and clothes, as she was replacing a lot of things for the New Year. To save money, I gladly accepted. She even offered to pay me weekly to help with my move to Douliu, which I appreciated.

However, things took a sudden bitter turn at the end of the third week.

On Friday night (2/7), while I was lesson planning, the other foreign teacher asked me to go for a walk. He told me that the boss and local teachers had been complaining about me not submitting lesson plans on time and being late to class. I explained that I had submitted them, but he said they should have been turned in exactly when requested (though I was never given a deadline).

At that moment, the stress got to me, and I broke down emotionally in front of him. I apologized and promised to try harder. That night, I considered quitting, but I showed up the next day anyway. However, I only smiled at the kids and kept a poker face with everyone else.

Second Reprimand (Saturday, 2/8 – Work Day)
That day, I skipped breakfast and focused on preparing my lessons. I had a lunch break from 12:10–4:30, but I skipped lunch as well to get ahead on lesson planning.

While I was working, the boss suddenly approached me and reprimanded me in front of staff and students. She accused me of being unprofessional, a bad teacher, disrespectful, rude, and a liar. She said, “We are not friends, we are colleagues,” and warned that if I didn’t follow her instructions, I would lose my ARC and have to leave the country.

The entire time she was speaking, I stared out the window to avoid breaking down. She took this as disrespect and tried to force me to look at her. I told her I couldn’t because I would cry, to which she said, “That’s fine. Kids do it all the time.” She then insisted I at least stand up, so I did. When I sighed, she mocked me, saying that only she had the right to be frustrated.

I apologized to her and everyone present, but she still said my apology was insincere.

Third Reprimand (Monday, 2/10)
That night, I messaged her asking for a copy of my contract (I didn’t have one). She immediately reprimanded me again, saying she knew I wanted to quit because I was asking for the contract.

I clarified that I just wanted to check my payment date. It was nearly midnight, and she still hadn’t transferred my salary. Instead of responding about payment, she continued criticizing me for being late, not submitting plans, and being unprofessional, saying I couldn’t compare to the other foreign teacher.

Then, she demanded that I return the second-hand items she had given me, forcing me to bring them back myself. I agreed.

Shortly after, some money appeared in my account. I politely messaged her again, asking if she could confirm when she had transferred the salary and provide a breakdown of my hours. To date, I have not received that breakdown.

Fourth Reprimand (Tuesday, 2/11)
That morning, I sent her a message informing her that I would finish the semester and leave in August.

Later, while I was preparing for class, she approached me again and started reprimanding me. She mocked my gestures, read into my emotions, and called me the same names as before.

Fifth Reprimand (Wednesday, 2/12)
I wasn’t informed that more students had been added to my class, so I didn’t print enough worksheets. During class, I had to step out to retrieve more worksheets from the printer.

There were 22 students packed into one small classroom, and I was the only teacher. While I was at the printer, the boss confronted me again, reprimanding me for not being prepared and not improving fast enough. She accused me of wasting paper and being disrespectful.

I offered to pay for the paper, but she took it as another sign of disrespect. She yelled at me, moved close to my face while waving her arms, and crumpled up a piece of paper near my face.

I finally told her, “It’s obvious you want me to leave. Just say it.” But instead, she kept asking if I wanted to leave. I kept saying no.

Then, she snapped: “Just go. Go. Go. Go. Go. Get out.”

I told her I needed a signed contract termination letter. She refused at first, but after some back-and-forth, she finally had the front desk worker print and stamp it.

Now, I Don’t Know What to Do.
I need advice. Thank you.

2 Likes

I should add that I was not told about the budget limit, and that after I started sending the lesson plans to the work email, she got upset saying I should should have asked her for her personal email and send the lesson plans there. When I told her that I mentioned this to the front desk, she asked the front dest on the spot and the front desk worker said I hadn’t said anything, to which the boss said that she was not a liar, basically, I was.

[edit]
She sent the salary for January last night and had already deducted 18% tax (workers pay 18% tax if they quit prior to 6 months working). The argument about firing me happened this afternoon. Can I use this to get severance pay?

1 Like

You can go file a complaint with the Yunlin County of Labor in Douliu. In general, they are most concerned about you getting back pay and severance pay if any.

I’m of the view that it is always best to go in person especially if you do not speak Mandarin well.

Yunlin County Government Labor and Youth Affairs Development Department
Phone: 05-5522810
Mobile Representative Number: 0988-640526
No. 515, Section 2, Yunlin Road, Douliu City, Yunlin County, 640201

9 Likes

Thank you very much.

1 Like

I can’t speak for Douliu but generally cram schools are so common in Taiwan that if one was giving me crap, I’d be applying to other ones and wouldn’t stay at that place another day. The toxicity never gets any better and it seems the other foreign teacher is acting as her lapdog and that’s what she expects now.
However Douliu is a small town so I’m not sure how many other options there are or even your background in teaching.

The prior comment from foc about the labour board is an excellent one.

5 Likes

Dude… like why? This isn’t med school. You’re not an associate for a high powered law firm. It’s a buxiban ffs! Even teaching at a uni, I wouldn’t pull all-nighters…
Plus, you’re a Dad (or Mom?) of three, not a naive kid in his 20s just starting out teaching in Asia (I mean, I assume with 3 kids you’re not in your 20s…). Your priority is your family, not your crappy boss of a low rent clown school. But if you’re content with the buxiban route, there’s plenty that prepare everything for you and you don’t have to do a lick of work for them besides flick through a book 5 minutes before class. I’m not saying that’s a good way to teach, but it’d certainly be better for your health and sanity.

17 Likes

Douliu should be big enough that’s there’s a few other cram schools in the area.
Try them. That boss sounds like a nightmare.
If you can’t get employment just move back to Tainan or look for other cram schools in other towns. Sometimes it’s just the way it is. At least Tainan has more options.

5 Likes

yeah so what happened here is you got a dickhead of a boss and were totally getting used by that cram school.

I understand the want to do a good job with it, but: they only pay you for the hours you’re there. After you’re off the clock, that’s your time and they need to respect that.

As Drew said, it’s cram school, not med school. If they’re not providing materials for you to teach, find a different cram school that will. They exist - I teach at one at the moment. I go into work, I look at the book, I teach the book, I try to make some simple games, and then at the end of class I have a look at the next pages and think a little bit about what I’m going to do the next day.

It’s not laziness - it’s just that I really don’t need that much prep work, nor does the school expect it, nor do the parents really know or care.

Look around Douliu for a bit. You have some time now, at least😅 Shouldn’t be too hard to find a cram school that is much better than that shit. As far as the legal stuff goes (ala severance and the like), I honestly have no idea, so I’ll keep my mouth shut about that.

This does make me wonder - are you from one of the “big five” (US, UK+Ireland, Australia, Canada, New Zealand) English countries? I have heard they’re much happier to fuck over non-native speakers, and especially non-white non-natives. It’s not really material to what happened - got fucked by them either way - but I can’t help but be curious.

3 Likes

Honestly speaking, the schools and parents don’t want ambitious lesson plans. They just want to tick boxes off. It’s perhaps not the best way, but it is the way that keeps everyone happy.

They want a white guy who will get the books done and have nice check marks to show the parents that, look, your kids books have check marks. That means they’re learning English!

My first sem at the cram school I spent a ton of time working on just phonics and basic writing, as these kids had like no phonics at school so writing was a PITA for them. They didn’t comprehend how “ai” made a long a sound in Chair.

Suffice to say, while the kids (mostly) came out better off for having worked on it, we didn’t entirely finish all of the books (3 of them!) after, and this upset many of the parents. I could demonstrate that most of the kids could read words with more complex sounds well, but thats not strictly quantifiable as “progress” to a non-speaker/a non-fluent speaker

Tick marks in the book? That’s a clear sign of “progress.”

:man_shrugging::man_shrugging::man_shrugging:

4 Likes

Really sorry to hear your story, especially considering that you have a family to support. And I know how expensive (in money and energy) that moving to a new city can be. It definitely sounds like you ended up with a shitty school so perhaps at least count your blessings that even though it was a bad experience, you no longer have to go there again. But for the future, I would recommend showing your teeth a bit when confronted by workplace bullies to avoid getting pushed around and into a situation that endangers your happiness and sanity. A little fight goes a long way.

6 Likes