Tl;Dr, selfish car drivers don’t want a new vehicle lower on the size=priority scale to go on the highway as it would be “unfair” to them, who spent so much on buying a car for a slightly more comfortable single person space inefficient commute.
Govt. still refuses to implement the regulation, which has already passed all 3 readings, to allow Large Heavy motorcycles onto the highway. More than 12 years later the govt. still refuses to allow the regulation change to be put into effect. The govt. says they will check the survey this year and conduct another survey next year.
Pretty sure the Taiwan News article here get’s mixed up between Large Heavy Motorcycle (Red/Orange plate) and General/Standard Heavy Motorcycle (white plate).
In addition to calls for access to the highway system, the bikers want the government to ease restrictions on where heavy bikes can park, and make it legal to maneuver more like four-wheel vehicles on Taiwan’s roads. They would like heavy bikes to be able to use the inner lane on two-lane roads, and make left turns in the same manner as cars and buses, rather than perform the two-stage left turn as scooters are required.
I think this is where they are mixing up the classifications here. The advocates are talking about removing MANDATORY hook turns for motorcycles (which includes scooters) and removing no motorcycles markings (禁行機車) from inner lanes
I think this is the first event related to highway access since YouTuber and school teacher Poem of Rider was arrested by police earlier this year.
YouTuber and safety advocate, Owl Fuko, who is often shared on this websites for his discussion and proposed design improvements to many intersection which have come up in recent news due to deadly accidents was also detained and also had his equipment confiscated which is why it took him a while to get back to making videos.
Also as a reminder many of these groups and individuals are also safety advocates that advocate for stricter licensing and testing requirements, improved education, improved road/street design, revoking driving privileges for dangerous drivers, improved pedestrian environment etc.
A lot of rider groups here have police, fire and paramedics as members when I chat with them, the general discussion goes along the lines of.
“It’s safer on the motorway as you don’t have pedestrians or people on scooters and bicycles randomly crossing in front of you without looking, also the motorways are not set up for tolls on motorcycles so its always about money not safety”.
I can agree with the first statement, but you just swap to a different kind of idiot, the second one I don’t know enough about the toll system to comment, but it seams to be a lingering statement even if its been solved.
tbh, is quite BS as tolls here in TW are collected with an automatic system, I can understand they might need a slightly modified camera set-up to read plates also on the rear (while now only on the front) in the case you don’t have the e-tag, but with etage the procedure is completely automatic and read with radio frequencies at each toll gate.
Not a difficult fix, just no willingness
Tolls are all done with eTag now.
Prior to 2013 Taiwan’s toll highways which include the #1 North to South Highway, the #3 North to South, and the #2 East West Highway heading to Keelung, required users to purchase toll booth tickets at a cost of NT$40 per ticket, or pay cash at the cash booths in order to travel on these highways. In 2012 FETC began installing and testing electronic eTag gates but the old toll booths remained. Drivers could choose an eTag intsall (which originally cost money for the specialized equiment) or continue use the old tickets or cash (until the end of 2013).
That and the thousands of illegally parked vehicles. Would also help a little bit to alleviate traffic on regular roads by getting some of the vehicles off the regular roads.
I think even for expressways they should allow white plates that are about 125cc or above to use them if ridden without a passenger. Would reduce traffic on city roads and decrease commute times. Also probably more people choosing to commute on a motorcycle rather than a car.
For example Poem of Biker also showed how his commute from Nangang to Luzhou is almost twice as long on a white plate scooter as a red plate motorcycle because of the expressway.
This is “safe”…and this looks way better than my commute experience. Way less illegally parked vehicles.
But this is “dangerous”…
I think this is what was tried on the sections they opened up to motorcycles as a trial run, and they would be looking at a full roll out when the current contract is up for tender.
Again I would take this with a pinch of salt, as it just scuttlebutt from other riders and I don’t know the ins and outs of the system(and my shit language skills don’t help).
I thought they were also done by automatic numberplate recognition, and you get a bill every couple of months.
No I agree with the yellow and above on the express ways, there are not really that many of them anyway. (here in red)
There is a natural easy to see difference between the colour of the plates, trying to see the defence between a many 110 or a 125 not so easy at 70km. This would also bring with it all the problems of the badly ridden scooters by a generation who never really had a test, and would end up getting them all banned.
if u don’t have etag, yes, that’s still the way.
But that’s most people in Taiwan…
What’s needed is proper education, training, and actual enforcement.
This would be moving forward but wont change the people already in the system
With penalties to match.
Good businesspeople would find good engineers to solve this problem, if it were the problem
There are cameras that can see if motorcycles are speeding, right?
I think they know how to, even if it’s just turning the cameras round to pick up the back numberplate instead of the front. More of a case not wanting to invest until they have to.
govt be like “hahaha go fuck yourself poors”, if u don’t got a car, even a shitty slow Luxgen, are u actually a person even worth considering?
What a laughable excuse. The survey says people don’t like it!
But I suppose that’s Taiwan traffic. Anything people don’t like, even if it’s for the betterment of society, gets bulled into being shit.
Yeah. There’s no reason to bring bikes that need to get way up in their rev range onto the expressway. Need the extra power to be able to manoeuvre, get ahead or behind, get out of your own way, and most importantly, get the hell out if there’s stupidity around. If you’re already pushing a 150-250 cc bike pretty hard to maintain 70-90, you don’t got the ability to effectively remove yourself from someone’s blind spot, or worse, their blind merge.
Just as an un fair comparison UK motorways (equivalent of a Taiwan national highway) allows anything 50cc and above, but I have felt much safer on a 125cc with pillion in the uk, than I would with 250cc riding solo here.
In Italy min required to ride on Autostrade (i.e. UK motorways or Taiwan’s 國道) is 150cc, so it requires at least an A2 driving licence.
Never rode on the Autostrade in Italy, hows it feel with the driving style there?
As I say UK still feels safer even with a lower cc bike. Other parts of Europe I was always on a bigger bike but still always pretty safe (you get the idiots driver in every country).
Here I just feel people forget what mirrors are for and are not on the look out for bikes.
I love it, much more relaxed (ofc you have some sections where it is more hectic)
I especially love driving on the mountain sections of Autostrade, the scenery is beautiful.
News report from Large Heavy Motorcycle protest/event calling for access to highways for Large Heavy Motorcycles.
News also shows number of accidents from a 3 month period from Freeway 3A (the one freeway section that is opened for Large Heavy Motorcycles) and the Expressways 64, 74, and 88 the number of large heavy motorcycle (top number) accidents compared to passenger vehicles (bottom number).
More news relating to freeway access for large heavy motorcycles.
Freeway Bureau basically going to do another public survey via landlines and cellphone numbers…
Looks like they’re doing this to say see! “People don’t support it!” So the MOTC can have an excuse to push it under the rug for another few years.
ChatGPT translation of article:
Motorcycle Groups “Fight for Access to National Highways”! National Highway Bureau to Restart Poll in March, Results Expected in the Second Half of the Year.
According to statistics, by the end of last year, the number of large motorcycles in the country had reached 260,000, and the issue of road rights for this group continues to attract attention. Motorcycle groups have been advocating for the opening of national highways to motorcycles with engine capacities above 550cc, but related proposals have been repeatedly rejected by the Ministry of Transportation due to public opinion. To more accurately understand the public’s views on this issue, the National Highway Bureau recently launched a public tender, commissioning a polling company to conduct a public opinion survey via landline and mobile phones to gather the public’s stance on allowing large motorcycles on national highways, which will serve as a reference for future policies.
The National Highway Bureau stated that since the amendment of Article 92 of the Road Traffic Management and Penalty Act in 2011, motorcycles with engine capacities above 550cc have been allowed to drive on highways during specific periods and on designated sections announced by the Ministry of Transportation. However, a supplementary resolution by the Legislative Yuan at the time emphasized that there were still safety concerns from the public regarding the opening of national highways to large motorcycles. It required the Ministry of Transportation to plan the opening in stages, ensuring safety and controllable risks. Currently, large motorcycles are only allowed on expressways, and the open sections of national highways are very limited.
In response, the National Highway Bureau stated that the public opinion survey for this year will begin in March. The polling company commissioned will conduct telephone interviews with the public to understand their views on allowing large motorcycles (above 550cc) to travel on national highways. When calling, the surveyors will first explain that the survey is commissioned by the Ministry of Transportation’s National Highway Bureau and reassure the respondents to freely express their opinions. The National Highway Bureau emphasized that the survey will only collect background information such as gender, age group, educational level, and residential area for analysis purposes, and will not ask for other personal information. Therefore, the public is encouraged to participate in the survey with peace of mind.
For a long time, motorcycle road rights groups have actively advocated for opening national highways to large motorcycles, including submitting proposals on public policy platforms and repeatedly gathering at the Ministry of Transportation and national highway service areas to express their demands. However, the National Highway Bureau pointed out that the most recent public opinion survey conducted in 2022 showed a ratio of about 1:3:6 for full support, conditional support, and opposition, respectively. This indicates that the majority of the public still have concerns about road conditions, motorcycle driving characteristics, and safety distances on national highways. More efforts will be needed in the future to strengthen communication and advocacy with the public and local governments.







