“Largely positive”, I would say. I got invited there from Upwork back in October. They’re an enterprise client on Upwork, and I think they basically invited a ton of people with PhDs in STEM topics, as well as people working in other subjects like languages.
That said, so far I’ve only done like 6–7 hours of work on a single short project with them, and that project is currently paused. It was well paid — I’ve made US$950 or thereabouts up to now for that small amount of work — so I’m not complaining too much, but from the Slack and Discourse channels it looks like many people haven’t gotten any work at all.
The strategy with these companies seems to be to onboard as many people as possible for projects that might come up. So when you get work you get work and it’s fine, but I wouldn’t treat it as a regular source of income at all. I also wouldn’t expect them to be great at responding until there’s a project for you. Quite frustrating, but that’s how it is.
I haven’t done the AI interview yet. That’s quite recent, and there was some technical issue for ages where it wasn’t showing up for people coming from Upwork. It just appeared for me a couple of days ago and I haven’t gotten around to it yet. I’ll probably do it soon.
Anyway, I’d definitely recommend doing the onboarding and seeing how it pans out. It’s really not that much hassle — probably just identity verification, watching a couple of videos, and reading some stuff.
I’d recommend Outlier too. No idea how long it’ll last, but I’m getting quite a consistent stream of work from them at the moment and the project I’m on is fairly interesting (annotating and improving chemistry/biology/physics prompts involving complex reasoning stuff).
Best advice if you do get a project (on either platform) is probably just to read the instructions carefully and do your best to follow the rules and do a good job. I got promoted to a reviewer on the above project pretty quickly after just a handful of tasks, so I’m seeing all the low-quality junk many people submit. These platforms have to deal with quite a lot of spammers, AI-generated submissions (universally against the rules), people selling accounts so unqualified people can submit tasks, and just your common or garden people doing shitty work, so I think it’s pretty easy to get a decent source of income if you’re reasonably competent and careful.