Naked tourists caused a quake that killed 18 climbers ! So say Malaysian officials. Don’t do on Kinabalu what you do on Mt Blanc please.
Whopper doesn’t really think they caused the quake either, but I guess it is important to respect local customs. Many consider mountains sacred ground.
Chopping down thousands of hectares of trees and setting fire to what’s left, on the other hand, is apparently not disrespectful, and does not cause, oh, I dunno … landslides?
And funnily enough, the opinions of those terribly important local tribespeople don’t carry much weight in that regard.
“Respect other cultures” my ass. If they earn respect, they’ll get it. Otherwise, people will simply point and laugh at their hypocrisy and cargo-cult ignorance.
I saw this news and laughed out loud at the ridiculousness of it all. But then I wondered, what percentage of the people who make fun of Malaysians for believing nakedness caused some mountain god to get angry believe: An all powerful god had an angel visit a virgin, then ‘impregnated’ said virgin to have a son that he could have tortured and killed so that he could then forgive the sins of all mankind? People believe all kinds of silly things
I saw this news and laughed out loud at the ridiculousness of it all. But then I wondered, what percentage of the people who make fun of Malaysians for believing nakedness caused some mountain god to get angry believe: An all powerful god had an angel visit a virgin, then ‘impregnated’ said virgin to have a son that he could have tortured and killed so that he could then forgive the sins of all mankind? People believe all kinds of silly things [/quote]
I would give this a Recommend, but they still haven’t restored that function. So:
I saw this news and laughed out loud at the ridiculousness of it all. But then I wondered, what percentage of the people who make fun of Malaysians for believing nakedness caused some mountain god to get angry believe: An all powerful god had an angel visit a virgin, then ‘impregnated’ said virgin to have a son that he could have tortured and killed so that he could then forgive the sins of all mankind? People believe all kinds of silly things [/quote]
It does sound outlandish when you strip off all the bells and whistles and only the naked undercarriage remains but not as outlandish as the idea that via some unknown process intelligent life will emerge from that pond in your backyard if only enough time passes and enough fortuitous lightening strikes hit it.
All well and good but the reaction here has been extreme because government policies mean people here can’t have their beliefs challenged without going nuts or invoking the charge of provoking racial harmony.
That said plenty of malaysians also said what finley did. But disrespect toward any culture here is not going to win you any support and there are serious legal repercussions. Locals could face sedition charges for doing what the Canadians did.
You just made that up stuff about ponds and lighting, then called it an unknown and outlandish idea. You may as well have written, “look how little I comprehend!”
But I digress. I think it’s silly to get naked when they should have known they were in a very conservative country. But thinking they angered a mountain god is one degree dumber.
You just made that up stuff about ponds and lighting, then called it an unknown and outlandish idea. You may as well have written, “look how little I comprehend!”
But I digress. I think it’s silly to get naked when they should have known they were in a very conservative country. But thinking they angered a mountain god is one degree dumber.[/quote]
Thank you for the compliment but there’s actually an entire scientific field devoted to the study of the origin of life: I admittedly simplified things by leaving out the possibility that we might have also all descended from fortuitous asteroid strikes.
[quote]Abiogenesis (/ˌeɪbaɪ.ɵˈdʒɛnɨsɪs/ ay-by-oh-jen-ə-siss[1]), or biopoiesis,is the natural process of life arising from non-living matter, such as simple organic compounds. It is thought to have occurred between 3.8 and 4 billion years ago, and is studied through a combination of laboratory experiments and extrapolation from the genetic information of modern organisms in order to make reasonable conjectures about what pre-life chemical reactions may have given rise to a living system.
The study of abiogenesis involves three main types of considerations: the geophysical, the chemical, and the biological,with more recent approaches attempting a synthesis of all three. Many approaches investigate how self-replicating molecules, or their components, came into existence. It is generally accepted that current life on Earth descended from an RNA world,although RNA-based life may not have been the first life to have existed. The Miller–Urey experiment and similar experiments demonstrated that most amino acids, basic chemicals of life, can be synthesized from inorganic compounds in conditions intended to be similar to early Earth. Several mechanisms have been investigated, including lightning and radiation. Other approaches (“metabolism first” hypotheses) focus on understanding how catalysis in chemical systems in the early Earth might have provided the precursor molecules necessary for self-replication. Complex organic molecules have been found in the solar system and in interstellar space, and these molecules may have provided starting material for the development of life on Earth.
According to the panspermia hypothesis, microscopic life—distributed by meteoroids, asteroids and other small Solar System bodies—may exist throughout the universe. It is speculated that the biochemistry of life may have begun shortly after the Big Bang, 13.8 billion years ago, during a habitable epoch when the age of the Universe was only 10–17 million years.[/quote]
Yes, but abiogenesis is not what you described in your previous post. Abiogenesis and evolution, as described by scientists, rather than the strawman descriptions presented by creationists, are not outlandish at all.
Newsflash: British people, Canadians and Malaysians are idiots. The former two of the entitled childish YOLO hahaha travel is FUN variety,the latter of the entitled childish respect our cultcha variety.
…showing that you can’t comprehend the snippet you posted. I love it when people use their ignorance of how this science stuff works as evidence of its implausibility and attempt to make the great dude in the sky more plausible.
Oh great mountain God, please do not tremble at the sight of my shockingly enormous member, for I must urinate upon thee! I heed not these scientists and their blasphemous talk of tectonic plates, but beg your mercy for my weak bladder.
It does sound outlandish when you strip off all the bells and whistles and only the naked undercarriage remains but not as outlandish as the idea that via some unknown process intelligent life will emerge from that pond in your backyard if only enough time passes and enough fortuitous lightening strikes hit it.[/quote]
But no more outlandish than the idea that via some unknown process a God will emerge out of thin air to create intelligent life and the pond to boot. Probably somewhat less, truth be told.
I saw this news and laughed out loud at the ridiculousness of it all. But then I wondered, what percentage of the people who make fun of Malaysians for believing nakedness caused some mountain god to get angry believe: An all powerful god had an angel visit a virgin, then ‘impregnated’ said virgin to have a son that he could have tortured and killed so that he could then forgive the sins of all mankind? People believe all kinds of silly things[/quote]
Come on guys. The only person who doesn’t believe in silly things is Mr Spock, and the popularity of that character revolved around putting him in situations where ‘logic’ was inadequate, such as teaching female aliens about lurve.
Just off the top of my head, here are some silly, irrational things that clever people believe in, some subset of whom probably don’t believe in virgins etc:
fiat currency can be used for settlement of debts and as a store of value (works only as long as people believe it’s true - ask a Zimbabwean)
a planned economy will result in a human utopia (regularly disproved from bitter experience, but there’s always someone who still wants to give it another go)
if you lend billions to people who have no job and no intention of paying it back, everything will work out just fine (admittedly a lot of people have lost that religion since 2008)
murder is bad and philanthropy is good (because it just is).
your mum loves you (presupposes the existence of ‘love’; circular at best).
People also believe in things that may seem like superficially plausible ideas but are not subject to falsification - someone mentioned abiogenesis. They’re basically just hand-waving and people who believe in them can only take them on faith.
The problem with the ‘naked Dutchmen on mountains cause earthquakes’ assertion is that it’s both irrational and falsifiable. You can use your imagination re. experimental protocol.
[quote=“finley”]Come on guys. The only person who doesn’t believe in silly things is Mr Spock, and the popularity of that character revolved around putting him in situations where ‘logic’ was inadequate, such as teaching female aliens about lurve.[/quote]False dichotomy. I don’t believe in silly things and I’m nothing like Spok. I’m sure you’re aware human personality extends beyond personal beliefs.
[quote=“finley”]Just off the top of my head, here are some silly, irrational things that clever people believe in, some subset of whom probably don’t believe in virgins etc:
fiat currency can be used for settlement of debts and as a store of value (works only as long as people believe it’s true - ask a Zimbabwean)
a planned economy will result in a human utopia (regularly disproved from bitter experience, but there’s always someone who still wants to give it another go)
if you lend billions to people who have no job and no intention of paying it back, everything will work out just fine (admittedly a lot of people have lost that religion since 2008)
murder is bad and philanthropy is good (because it just is).
your mum loves you (presupposes the existence of ‘love’; circular at best).
animals deserve humane treatment (because it’s ‘obvious’).[/quote]These are real phenomenon that can be observed, measured, and/ or debated in society. Economists can debate loans, flat currencies and economic approaches in the real world. None of your examples are at all analogous to what we were discussing.
[quote=“finley”]People also believe in things that may seem like superficially plausible ideas but are not subject to falsification - someone mentioned abiogenesis. They’re basically just hand-waving and people who believe in them can only take them on faith.[/quote]Abiogenesis is hardly hand waving. It’s a solid theory for the origin of life, and as already stated, a better explanation than the no explanation of an uncreated god who just snapped his fingers.
[quote=“finley”]The problem with the ‘naked Dutchmen on mountains cause earthquakes’ assertion is that it’s both irrational and falsifiable. You can use your imagination re. experimental protocol.[/quote]Would you not say virgin births are at least equally falsifiable? I think that’s an incredibly silly thing to believe, at least as silly as a mountain god that gets angry about nudity. And an all powerful God who needs to have a son just to kill him so that every human does not spend eternity burning in hell is equally irrational. And what are the chances that Jesus rose from the dead while his mother didn’t die, but was whisped straight up into heaven via what must have been a several light year journey to heaven? To paraphrase the late Christopher Hitchens, religion makes otherwise intelligent people believe all kinds of silly things.
If the latter part of your sentence is true, then the first part of your sentence is false. Ask Spock.
Obviously. Still, you have some personal beliefs, and some of those are (I’m certain) highly illogical, Captain.
One particular virgin birth 2000 years ago; so in that case, no. Anyway, you boiled down the religion to a parody, just as somebody subsequently did with yours (which caused you to get all offended )
As I said, the latter is scientifically falsifiable. The former is simply a belief that may or may not be true (and nobody is going to arrest you if you believe that it isn’t … well, not these days, anyway). We can respect your opinion, but “I think” doesn’t really settle the matter beyond all reasonable doubt.
Again, that’s just a parody. You can make anything sound silly if you fiddle with it a bit, as per the fishpond-and-lightning post. I don’t want this to go off on a tangent about religion, but the entire point of all that was human need, not God’s needs.
Chances? A sample of one doesn’t submit to statistical analysis. And how do you know heaven is several light years away?
So what? People debate them because they don’t have cut-and-dried answers, and can be proven either true of false depending on your starting axioms. Some people believe one side of the argument, some people believe the other. Some things that ‘intelligent people’ believe have been proven false by scientific experiment (again, just off the top of my head: “cholesterol causes heart disease”, “ploughing a field is good for the soil”) but they still believe them anyway. The key word here is ‘believe’.
Hitchens was a smart guy and I love his writing. But beliefs in general, I think, should be assessed on their impact, not on their “obvious” silliness (or “obvious” correctness). The world is awash with beliefs that cannot be proven one way or the other, but which we nevertheless accept as true or false. Those beliefs have various social impacts; to get back to the original case, I suggest (a) the belief is not even strongly held, for the reasons I gave earlier and (b) it should be discarded because we know what causes earthquakes (ie., nothing - they happen at random) and societies that can’t accept that fact are ill-prepared for them.
Strictly speaking, neither is falsifiable because zero evidence exists to test the magical ideas. Both ideas are so silly that don’t deserve falsification. But even if I play along, both are equally ridiculous. Actually, a virgin birth is much easier to falsify. Since the time scientists have come to understand how earthquakes happen, how many have we had. Hundreds? Just because we can’t go back in time to test past earthquakes doesn’t mean that a mountain god was ever a possible cause. We understand that there is zero evidence of such a being and in light of actual facts, we can say it’s not at all reasonable to believe in a mountain god. Same with virgin births. How many millions of babies have been born since microscopes could physically see sperm swimming towards an egg? And how many immaculate conceptions? Zero. And we don’t need to worry about going back in time to give Mary a gyno exam because we know exactly what conditions create a baby. Spoiler alert if no one has had the talk with you: virgity makes conception impossible! So let me replace “I think” with a statement that anyone can very confidently claim: Mary was not a virgin. It’s delusional to believe she was.
[quote]Again, that’s just a parody. You can make anything sound silly if you fiddle with it a bit, as per the fishpond-and-lightning post. I don’t want this to go off on a tangent about religion, but the entire point of all that was human need, not God’s needs.[/quote]Speaking as a human, I can say that I don’t want anyone to be tortured and executed for my sake, nor for the sake of my eternal soul, especially given there is zero evidence of such a thing.
Exactly. A sample of one means nothing, especially when that example has no evidence to suppoert it. But we could test this. We could crucify one hundred people, stick them in a tomb, and reopen after three days. I’m confident none would come back to life. Probably because we would need one hundred people born of virgins to really recreate the conditions. Luckily, we don’t need the experiment because the same reasoning can be applied to rising from the dead as virgin births, ie, we know the physical conditions (the brain cannot survive without oxygen for long,) are absolutely verifiable, and can conclude that there is no way jesus came out of that cave after 3 days. None.
So why do I care? Exactly because of cases like this. These four were arrested for public indecency, so fair enough. But they were arrested only after pressure from an ignorant populace. These kinds of beliefs are stupid. They deserve nothing but parody. Saudis will kill you for insulting Islam. Isis killed pigeons recently because seeing their genitals when they fly above is insulting to god. Catholics believe everyone who is not baptized in their church and does not swallow their doctrine whole will be condemned to eternal suffering. All religion shares a love of silliness.