Effect of mini tremors on building's structure

I was trying to count how many times a day the whole bunker where I work shakes with movement either provocked when heavy military or news trucks go by or someone throws loads of materials -books, furniture, whatever it is- or they start their parades and tap dancing -don’t ask. Some days it is not that much but like today it has been a doozy.

The thing is that these movements feel like small tremors, say, maybe a 4 or 5 pointer, with the corresponding rumble and all that. Walls creak, windos rattle, floor wobbles. My question is that these structures are yes, designed to withstand quakes, but how about constant vibrations/movements/plain jumping? Someone was pointing out one of our columns looks tilted… Is there something like metal fatigue on concrete and/or bricks?

Hence, I suspect that the structure is compromised and in a real hard quake we’ll be history.

This is the case for the whole of Taipei. 7.5 in downtown Taipei? There would be countless buildings pancaking or semi-collapsing. Everyone knows this, no one wants to talk about it. We don’t even do earthquake drills here for gods sake.

Nothing in Taiwan except maybe Taipei 101 would withstand a meaningful earthquake AFAIK. The build quality simply isn’t there. Lives are too cheap here. I’ve seen and heard stuff that would make an Australian tradesman freak out.

Rubbish, any of the tall buildings built in the last 20 years should do fine in a big earthquake, and the gongyu 5 story buildings are solid as f$@k, built of reinforced concrete and linked together in long rows.

Not from what I’ve seen and heard. Maybe I have an overly pessimistic view but what trade work goes on here would be sued out of existence in my native country.

I wonder how old those complexes that pancaked in Kaohsiung were?

You mean the Weiguan Jinlong complex in Tainan? 21 years old when it collapsed.

I arrived in Taiwan just in time for 921. Rule of thumb after that, or at least vox populi, was that if any structure stood that, it would stand anything else afterwards. 331 made everyone worry about Taipei 101, but so far, so good.

Fast forward 20 years -well, almost, over 15 for 921 and 12 for Taipei 101- and the problem is that Taipei is jammed packed with old gonwus that are 40 to 30 years old. A 20 year old building is considered new, and if you notice, most 20 year od places are high rises with elevators, not gonwus. All, old or new, high rise or gonwu, have taken a beating over the years due to constant tremors. That is for me another worry

So far, after 921, we haven’t had that massive destruction as I have witnessed in the ol country after a 7 pointer, block after block of collapsed structures, city center all wiped off. Buildings you thought could take anything leaning sideways. Debris everywhere, especially glass.

It stands to say that Taiwanese building materials are of better quality. Moreover, the buildings that have problems, show them early on, and that is my point. We all know by word of mouth which buildings in the hood were not built even up to the lax building standards of the Island. One high rise in particular is supposed to be high end and all, but built over a feeble base on a landfil. Gonwus were built with higher quality materials -except the radiation beams- to live in, and by at that time a bit more affluent people -civil servants-hence the care.

In Taipei, only now they are paying a bit more concern -at least, they are talking about it- to the proness to liquifaction in certain areas. That is something you can prepare beforehand. Unlike resonance. Still, centenial buildings and hastily built structures, especially the ones that house crowds -think how many schools, universities and public offices and facilities fall into this category. Plus most have inadequate escape routes, emergency exits… when they are supposed to be first responders.

Yes, that’s what I meant. My memory is getting the locations mixed up. Earthquake centered in Kaohsiung, damage in Tainan.

Wiki says that the building’s support structures included cooking oil cans and styrofoam mixed with concrete. My friend worked on the gate at CKS Memorial Hall when it was recently renovated. He said it was made of concrete and handfuls of scrap metal, and he also saw pylons at other sites of hollow brick-and-mortar filled with concrete and scrap metal. When he was welding at an MRT station he was told speed was better than safety, and if anything broke later the company would happily get more work when called out to fix it.

Obviously this is all just anecdotes but I’ve seen other dodgy trade work around here and it doesn’t inspire confidence.

PS: Glad the JAMS are here at Forumosa to sort out this Illuminati business. ALL BOUND FOR MU-MU LAND.

The OP didn’t give us any real info about his/her building. It would be important to know how old it is, and how tall.

After the disastrous 9/21 earthquake (1999), building standards were considerably upgraded. Most new buildings are made with reinforced concrete and I have reasonable faith in them.

Aside from quality building construction, one other safety factor that is a bit less obvious is whether or not the structure is located on a “dip slope.” This has caused a few disasters in Taiwan:

From what I understand, it was the location on a dip slope that led to the Lincoln Mansions disaster in 1997:

Part if it is a centennial Japanese era structure. Another part is a 1950s hastily add on, with another patch in the early 70s or late 60s. Latest addition were the roof solar panels about 6 to 8 years ago.

We are 4 floors above ground, 3 or 2 levels under. I am not sure if the bomb shelter is condemned or filled up.

Thanks for the building description. The good news is that it’s probably not constructed of empty salad oil cans (otherwise, it would be collapsed by now). Bad news is that it’s probably just a pile of bricks held together by cement, with little in the way of steel reinforcement. Those brick piles can be pretty durable, but if hit by “The Big One” all bets are off.

I don’t expect to live forever and am willing to take risks, but personally I don’t like the idea of being squished in an earthquake. It could ruin your whole day.

I intentionally live in a one-story building. At least there is less to collapse on top of me. And it has the added benefit of not requiring me to walk up stairs. No worries about flooding in the basement either, since there isn’t one. On the other hand, I’d be S.O.L. if I needed a bomb shelter.

I’m in rural Taiwan. I realize it’s hard to find a one-story house in Taipei. Good luck.

The solar panels - I’m a bit curious about how effective those are. In the past decade, a lot of people installed those to collect government subsidies, but how well they work depends on some factors, an important detail being how much direct sunlight they are exposed to. Are the panels on your building well-positioned? A big problem in cities is when buildings are not of uniform height, so that shadows from taller buildings create shade on the rooftops of neighboring buildings. Obviously, it varies at different times of the day as the sun angle changes. Anyway, anything you can tell us about the panels would interest me.

cheers

:joy: As the Latina character in Pitch perfect said, I have lived longer than I would have expected. Yet, I also do not want to end up my days squished like a bug. I have already survived like 8 over 7 pointers, including 2 over 8 pointers, both here in Taiwan and the ol country. The more I suffer through earthquakes, the more I respect them and appreciate that the ground beneath our feet is not solid.

In the ol country, we have enough room for one floor residences. In teh past, we prefereed wood structures. Here in Taiwan they set them msot one floor houses in the mountains -slopes- and that has its own problems.

However, the biggets problem I have is that this bunker is my home 12 hours a day or more. I spend more time at work than at home. At least we are close to the fire station. But their building is older and shabbier than ours.

I’d hazard a guess at some more good news then–it’s not, like much of Taipei, built on reclaimed swampland.

I have a question. I live in a building that has 24 floors, looks old but I don’t know how many years exactly. How do I find out when was it built? I live in new taipei city.

and the gongyu 5 story buildings are solid as f$@k, built of reinforced concrete and linked together in long rows.

Wow, I beg to differ. Gongyu (that’s how it’s spelled, Icon! :slight_smile: ) 's can be of any quality. I have had the pleasure to live in one that was of an extremely poor build. We moved out after a few months. The ceilings (floors) were extremely thin. Children playing on the floor above us made the ceiling lamp move. Voices could be heard through it. I am not exaggerating saying that was just as bad as a wooden ceiling. There were water leak problems too. All those vibrations will cause pipes in the floors to leak. This was an early 80’s building in Xinyi district.
On the other hand, my parents in law’s gongyu is built really solid, high quality. So as you can see you can’t generalise about gongyu.

Would you pinyin crowd agree on just one spelling?! Hongkongwei corrected me to write gongwu. I was writing gongyu from the start. Pero como es la vaina?!
(Translation: so what is it this troublesome thing?)

Depends on the gongyu/gongwu. I guess mine, though older -early 60s I bet- were built by retired civil servants and military personnel. I know because we have the same floors, doors and color scheme as my office. They built it themselves -same materials I suppose. :smirk:

80s and such were build by companies for profit. Hence, the “quality”.

Actually, you remembered wrong. Here’s what he wrote:

I give up!