Insults

Been told to “go get hit by a car” and “go kill yourself” multiple times by my wife and when I challenged her behaviour she claimed these words are normal and not that bad in Taiwanese culture. Online searches suggest it’s very bad, even illegal depending on context.

I’d appreciate some human perspective on this as don’t want to just trust AI.

Where are they happening? At home or in public in view of others?

There is no culture where it’s normal or ok for a partner to tell their partner to kill themselves.

If someone thinks this kind of horrible talk is “normal,” it’s showing the massive dysfunction in their own families when they were growing up.

Since you understand it to be a problem, you need to say that this kind of talk is a problem. If your partner does not change after you make your plea, then my advice is to get a divorce.

Guy

‘You make me want to die’, ‘you drive me to death’, and ‘why don’t you die’, are pretty common expressions in domestic arguments in cantonese. Can’t see why mandarin/taiwanese/Taiwan would be that different.

That the culture card my wife use everytime she is wrong.

Not normal in a stable relationship, fairly normal in one that is heading to separation/divorce.

If my friend told me this, I would say “Why don’t you try talk to Counseling centre/ Psychologists (諮商心理師)”. Taiwanese seem more open to this and more common now to use these services. (In Taiwan, if your here there many more people that provide this services)

I think being married you want make it better. Me being single , can change easier and did do so, and learned it does not at all have be like that (going to much less stressful relationship is huge change!)

These are the things u learn while dating not after your marriage

These are things best learned while dating, not after your marriage.

But it’s never too late.

That’s domestic abuse.

If you don’t have kids, start looking into getting a divorce. This is not healthy for you. If you do have kids, try looking into how to get marriage counseling.

I think it’s insulting to Taiwanese people to suggest this is somehow normal in their culture. Millions of Taiwanese couples manage to argue without telling each other to commit suicide.

The only things that really matter here are how you feel about it, and if you’re willing to accept it or not.

In other words, even if what she said were true (it’s not), your culture (presumably :slight_smile: ) isn’t okay with such language. No one can insist on maintaining their own cultural norms in a marriage, more than anything else.

It’s not normal. I think I know the phrases you are referring to in mandarin if she is saying it.

你去死啦

This kind of comment if said is often said in an absurd comical context in Taiwan. For example someone suggesting you doing something you absolutely hate as a joke. It’s like a fuck off in this context

It’s very different if she’s throwing this type of thing out there during arguments regularly

Yea what Andrew said thats not such a bad comment. Kinda funny imo.

Go hit by a car sounds worse though.

Anyway mate its up to you, if it crosses your boundaries then its an issue.

No

Taiwanese people are very friendly
Friendly with Chinese characteristics
:joy:

Yes, but no, people all over the world who grew up in dysfunctional families say things like this, sure, but that does not make it right and it also does not make it an acceptable cultural norm.

My wife has never said anything like that, and the few times she’s said something that seemed “off” to me, we had a healthy conversation about it, and a few things she never said again because my interpretation was not what she meant. (For the record, this goes both ways!)

@xxxxx4 - y’all need to communicate! :joy:

Which can be difficult or impossible in the middle of an argument, but after the storm has passed you can say something like, “I feel like there may be some misunderstandings that is making our arguments worse, I reacted to [x] because in my culture it means [y] and is something nobody would ever say to their spouse, so to me it is like an unexpected attack. I’m sure there are things I am saying that are like that for you too.”
Etc…

As a small tip from my wonderful wife - a husband always says “yes” to whatever the wife wants, even if the answer is “no”, just say it in a way that lets her know it’s a problem, e.g. “Of course we can do/go/buy [whatever], if you want it then we will find a way to make it happen.”

(It’s a face thing, not all women are alike, lol.)

Did you challenge her right then and there, or did you wait until she’d calmed tf down?

You can’t expect people to just switch channels to reasonability if they’re flying off the handle.

Yeah just tell her to calm down :exploding_head: