[quote=âChickenâ]My âappallingly illogical argumentâ was meant to point out the logical fallacy in the knee jerk objections I received. If you really canât think of a good reason to have kittens then I canât help you. But I will take another stab at it. Say you all have your way. No one ever has a cat on purpose again. The only cats you can take home were born on the street (that is what your asking me to do). What is the result? Only feral cats in homes. I do not want a feral cat. I want a cat that was born in a loving home.
Next. You popooed any psychological or biological arguments for having kittens. Well you are wrong. Spaying is a very intrusive surgery and there is plenty of evidence that cats are better of getting it as late as possible and after one litter of kittens. This is unlike neutering which can be done soon after maturity.
Ideally I would like to keep 1 kitten to have a 2 cat home. The rest will go to people who want them. You are right that after they leave my care I can not grantee that they will be fixed. Therefore, as it has been pointed out to me that cats do not have a high value, and to avoid your social/legal preventatives, I will have to euthanise them. Now do you feel better knowing they wonât be abandoned on the street? :loco:
No cats will be put down in my home, this was biting sarchasim
[/quote]
Sorry. Iâm not letting you have your thread back just yet. =)
Anyhow, Iâd like to lightly chide you for misreading what I wrote. My argument is not against anyone getting a kitten from wherever they want to get a kitten â off the street, from a friend, from a reputable breeder, plucked steaming from the womb of a championship chinchilla, whatever. All cats deserve a loving home, whether they come from a pet store or a ditch.
My point is the lack of loving homes, especially here in Taiwan. Actually, I CAN think of good reasons for breeding cats, and even better reasons for breeding dogs â that is, responsible breeding. That includes screening pets for temperament, genetic defects, and other specific qualities (i.e. hairless and dander-free animals, certain breeds bearing unique traits). There is and probably always will be a market for show animals and breed-specific animal lovers, and thatâs not my battle here. Pardon me for being presumptuous, but it doesnât sound like spawning a prizewinning line is your intention anyway.
You sound like a very proud, loving cat owner. And taking her overall health into mind, you seem pretty set on letting her have just one litter for good intentions â for the sake of her health, and hers alone. You can probably find plenty of citations that back your stance, but Iâm willing to bet that there are more citations in support of the exact opposite. Like I said, my familyâs own females were all spayed at about 6 months and theyâve all led perfectly pampered, healthy lives⌠oneâs about 15 years old and still kicking. Anyway, please just take a look. I donât think youâve bothered to look at anything Iâve thrown your way, otherwise you would notice that the majority of cats listed on those other sites Iâve sent you ARENâT feral cats â itâs obvious even if you canât read Chinese â and probably WOULD fit your simple description of a âcat that was born from a loving homeâ.
So if you want to drop another box of kittens into that queue, I canât stop you.
I donât know why I jumped into this whole debate anyway.
Maybe because I feel like thereâs clearly a better choice. <-- Not biting sarcasm, just disgruntled muttering.