Wonderful experience on the streets of San Francisco today! I just got back in the door, and after putting my daughter to bed, wanted to jump onboard with a few quick impressions.
First of all, all of my worst fears were absolutely not proven. ac_dropout, zeug, you guys can rest assured… I felt little hostility on the streets. I was up early with my flag, and I had several Americans pull over and explicitly tell me “just so you know… go China, I think it’s a shame what the protesters are doing to the Olympics.” I had only one critical comment from someone with a southeast Asian accent (Burmese?) telling me to stop the genocide. I told him I’d take it under consideration.
It was a glorious morning. As far as the eye could see south of AT&T Park was a flood of Chinese flags and passionate Chinese. There were numerous university banners held by proud alumni: Tsinghua, Beida, Wuhan Daxue… I wasn’t old enough to attend 6/4, but this gave me a far greater appreciation of how they must’ve felt in those heady days. Every Chinese flag in the state must’ve been bought; I thought my flags would be on the large side (I had 4 3’x5’ flags)… but we were absolutely over-shadowed by some of the huge flags on display. It was a wonderful feeling. We all helped each other, sharing water, instructions, news, helping make flags, learning new dances. A family friend who watched with us took the Caltrain up from the South Bay; they said that about 60% of the train crowd consisted of Chinese working in Silicon Valley technology companies.
There was also a confrontation with a far smaller crowd of Tibetan independence activists at the foot of AT&T Park. (Right across the bridge on 3rd street.) I had seen them walk up earlier, chanting and holding signs… (a small attachment of green Darfur protesters were attached to their hip). 5 minutes later, they were literally surrounded by probably 2x their number of pro-Chinese demonstrators. The cops quickly closed the bridge to foot traffic, to prevent additional Chinese from flooding into the area. It was a good shouting match… the head of the little Tibetan group (holding microphone) spoke in perfect putonghua, by the way. There was no physical contact while I was there, although emotions quickly began to run high. 30 minutes later, I heard a Tibetan protester got into a shoving match and was arrested.
All in all, we absolutely out-numbered them. It was probably a difference of a factor of 5x1. The pro-Chinese crowd was probably about 95% Chinese, while the Tibet independence crowd was probably 60% Tibetan, 40% white Americans. The Darfur crowd, by the way, was 100% white/young/college freshman looking people who probably couldn’t even enjoy a beer after the event ended.
I’m very grateful to the cops and the San Francisco city government. Every single cop was courteous and professional… firm at times, but very professional. I am ecstatic with San Francisco’s solution, even though it means I waited for hours in the sun without actually seeing the torch. They still allowed the torch to run successfully, and the immediate first-person accounts flooding the airwaves were from people expressing their awe and happiness at having seen the torch pass by miles from its original route. They handled a very difficult, potentially dangerous situation wonderfully. (I say this without knowing how the big crowd at the now canceled closing ceremony will resolve itself… but I assume it will resolve fine.)
San Francisco definitely lived up to its word today as a city which tolerates different opinions, and yet still assures enough security and stability such that these different opinions can be heard equally. So, way to go San Francisco. I look forward to the day when a Chinese city will be able to offer the same. (And that’s not JUST a political statement; it’s an economic/social as well as political statement.)
Before today, all of the news coverage exclusively talked about the demonstrators. It was all about the “thousands of demonstrators” who would be greeting the torch. Today, pro-Chinese supporters heavily out-numbered the anti-Chinese demonstrators heavily… but there’s also no doubt everyone got a chance to have their say. I’m just very happy that we were able to stand up and make our voices heard. tuanjie jiushi liliang!!!