There’s been a simmering debate over whether or not it is appropriate to accept aid from rival powers in times of hardship. The debate was pretty fierce in some quarters after 9/11, came up again after the tsunami, Hurricane Katrina, and the earthquake in Pakistan.
My view is that recognizing the pain of others and donating, or from the other side, acknowledging one’s own fragility and vulnerability and accepting aid, isn’t a sign of weakness, but of strength and courage.
(Yeah, yeah… sounds ‘touchy-feely’, right? Check out what Machiavelli (hardly a soft touch) says about extending a hand to a rival caught in the river.)
Gestures that might not mean much in the grand scheme of things can have immense symbolic value and snowball into something that provides momentum to move in a positve direction.
Here’s a great example. A minute gesture in the grand scheme of things, but a tremendous gift for the particular individuals involved.
Any thoughts on the morality of this individual man’s act? As the action of an individual, it is different than the act of a state, but the principle is the same. Thoughts on the potential political impact (and this guy is clearly aware of the political dimensions) of such an act?
Israelis receive organs from Palestinian boy shot by troops
[quote]The father of a Palestinian boy shot dead by Israeli soldiers has donated his son’s organs to Israelis waiting for transplants.
Ismail Khatib said the spirit of his 12-year-old son Ahmed is now alive in every Israeli and that he’s proud of his decision.
He said he understands some Palestinians may be angered by the move.
“No one can tell me what to do,” Khatib told the Associated Press. “I feel very good that my son’s organs are helping six Israelis … I feel that my son has entered the heart of every Israeli.”
Ahmed was shot during a raid in Jenin. Israeli troops said he was carrying a toy rifle and they mistook him for a militant.
He died of his wounds late Saturday at an Israeli hospital.
His kidneys, liver, lungs and heart were transplanted to recipients, ranging in age from a seven-month-old baby to a 58-year-old woman. Those who received organs included Jews, Arabs and a Druze girl.
Khatib said his decision was made in part by experiences with his brother, who died at the age of 24 while waiting for a liver transplant. He said it’s his family’s desire to help others regardless of their nationality.
“We’re talking about young children. Their religion doesn’t make a difference,” he said.
Israel has a chronic shortage of donor organs. Medical officials attribute it to Jewish religious taboos against such donations.
Khatib said he received a call from Israel’s acting finance minister, Ehud Olmer, who apologized for the boy’s death and invited him to Jerusalem. Khatib said he had not decided whether to accept the offer. [/quote]