[quote=“jimipresley”][quote=“bismarck”]
It was such a nice two weeks of Tri-Nations for me, and now it’s back to worrying about PdV clownishness for another three weeks.[/quote]
Ah, the fickle SA rugby crowd. Dominate world rugby for a coupla years, then lose a match or two and your arse is cheese.
[/quote]
Sorry, mate, but you’re talking out your pooper on that one. It’s one thing to be behind the team when they win, and flame them when the lose one or two or three; and it’s quite another thing to be pissed with the coach (who I’ve been saying since he was appointed in late 2007 is utter shite and is going to get us in deep crap eventually) who doesn’t seem to know the difference between an inside center and a wing, an in form scrum half and a mediocre provincial has been, and who plays one guy from the northern hemisphere but excludes the greatest natural talent this country has had in a century. Not to mention embarrassing us with stupid comments, acting like a arse clown in public, supporting thuggish behaviour to ingratiate himself with “the boys” to cover up his coaching inadequacies and generally piss poor performances.
You conveniently forget some of his other gaffs in the last three years, which clearly indicates it’s no where near a case of “lose a game or two and your arse is cheese”.
16 Aug 2008 SA 0 - 19 NZ (Cape Town)
23 Aug 2008 SA 15 - 27 AUS (Durban)
4 Jul 2009 SA 9 - 28 Lions (Johannesburg) We won the series, but were very lucky to win the second test and we were thrashed in the third test. Hardly convincing stuff from the coach. I’d bet anything Jake would have coached the Boks to a 3-0 whitewash of the Lions. But no one was too worried yet. However, the cracks had started to show, even though we dominated the Tri-Nations (although, the All Blacks had a terrible season overall, and the Aussies had just started fielding a practically new young team), and the dam wall burst in November 2009.
6 Nov 2009 SA 17 - 22 Leicester Tigers
13 Nov 2009 SA 13 -30 France
17 Nov 2009 SA 23 - 24 Saracens
Fortunately, the next weekend we played against lowly Italy. Wow! What a “big” score we managed there! 
21 Nov 2009 SA 32 - 10 Italy But still, at least it was a win. However, I think I could have coached the Boks that week, and they still would have won.
28 Nov 2009 SA 10 - 15 Ireland That was the worst international I have ever seen the Boks throw away. We’ve been well beaten before, but that game was utter rubbish in how they totally tossed away all their scoring opportunities.
5 Jun 2010 SA 34 - 31 Wales Barely scrapped a victory against a side that was well beaten several times in the Six Nations.
12 Jun 2010 SA 42 - 17 France And before you get excited about that score, remember that two weeks later the Argies managed this score: Argentina 41 - 13 France. This is the same Argentine team that managed to lose twice to Scotland in the two previous weeks (Argentina 16 - 24 Scotland, and Argentina 9 - 13 Scotland). So it’s safe to say we were lucky to escape with a win in Wales in June, thumped a French side which was utter crap and a shadow of it’s 2009 form, having just come out of a very long northern season. But this result, in of itself, is nothing to be alarmed about. This happens every June, and we hear the same excuses every year. The scraping past Wales is much more damning. Then, apart from the big win (as it should be) in the second test against Italy, in the first test we repeat the shit form from Nov 2009.
19 Jun 2010 SA 29 - 13 Italy Only, in Italy in Nov 2009 we managed a 22 point margin, and in this first test we managed a mere 16 point margin. If it wasn’t for the 44 point arse raping we gave them in East London there could have been a good argument for a case that Nick Mallet was closing the gap between the Boks and Italy! Although, out of three tests in seven months between these two countries it’s clear as daylight that Mallet is in a completely different league than PdV. The only difference is Mallet is coaching a bunch of mediocre players to perform heroic tests, and PdV is coaching magnificent players in a country with awesome depth to mediocre (or worse) test performances. And this became clear as crystal in this year’s Tri-Nations:
24 Jun 2010 SA 13 - 30 Australia
17 Jun 2010 SA 17 - 31 New Zealand
10 Jun 2010 SA 12 - 32 New Zealand
This is typical of 3N performances before Jake White took over where we had gotten used to being thrashed in Australia and NZ and beating Aussie in SA, and lucky if we manage a sole home win against NZ. This is going backwards ten years. Not achieving dominance, let alone parity with the other two top three rugby nations. When one looks at the performances of the Stormers and the Bulls in the Super 14 there is no logical reason for this. The Stormers beat all the NZ teams and only had one away loss to the Reds in Brisbane. The Bulls beat the Crusaders twice, performed well overall and managed to down even the Stormers in the Final to win the S14.
These are the same players, but with a different coach. If we had lost the above three tests, but could at least say we had played well, then it would be a different thing entirely. But they played utter shit rugby, the coached whinged about cheating, couldn’t adapt to the way the refs were interpreting the laws, there was no defence, no attacking structure, poor discipline and generally no game plan.
When the players have run the show and been allowed to play Jake’s game we’ve done well. When the coach has experimented, we’ve been thrashed (and humiliated by English club sides who are not even in the same league as the lower half of the Super 14 table).
Your comment above is erroneous because it’s not a case of being happy when we win for years, and grilling them when they lose one or two. We’ve been lucky to face shoddy opposition, and the only top nations we’ve faced and beaten in the last year has been Wales (barely) and France (who were equally arse raped by Argentina), but we’ve managed to lose to France away from home, the Irish, Australia and New Zealand. We have a Grand Slam tour coming up in November, and I can guarantee you now we’re not going to pull it off. In fact, I think we’ll lose at least two of the five games, if not three or four. Let’s just hope we can continue our good run against the Barbarians and win that game, at least.
It’s pissed me off that other posters have posted here recently that Aussie will get at least one win in SA, but I’ve declined to comment, because they’re right. If Cooper and Genia are reunited with Giteau at no.12 their backline will be too much for PdV’s illogical selections and piss poor discipline that he instills. Their loosies will destroy ours again, and we’ll be lucky to escape with one win out of three home games if something drastic isn’t done.
It’s not that we don’t have the depth or the talent. In fact, with the coaches and players we have that have consistently performed over the last three to five years, given the correct structures and staff with decent selections we should have won at least one away game and come away with one or two bonus point losses well poised to defend our Tri-Nations title with the outcome of the tournament still very much in doubt, and three home games (at altitude!) in hand.
So, no. It’s not the team. It’s not depth. It’s not lack of talent. It’s a politically appointed clown with no coaching pedigree worth a damn who has managed what no one else could possibly have done: Take a world class pool of players, a world class team and drive them to the pits of mediocrity.
And it’s not something I’ve only been saying of late. I’ve been saying it since he was appointed after the 2007 RWC. Sadly, I’ve been proven correct.