Should Taiwan Create an Earthquake Prediction Center?

TaiwanTeacher: I think Zender was being facetious… The list above shows 80 quakes all SSW of Hualian County with an average distance of 35km each…

In addition, however, you would be correct to make a presumption that a bigger quake may occur along the east coast. I must reiterate that prediction is possible as I have seen it work. Accuracy is still seems to be an issue, however, and with current models it may or may not ever improve over time…

Actually, if that Hualian sequence is all aftershocks, then it’s very predictable. The number of aftershocks of each magnitude tends to be very consistent. So zender’s prediction is a good one, since there are still more to come :thumbsup: . That’s probably the one situation where you can predict earthquakes. Of course it doesn’t help all that much, since you can’t do it until the biggest one, the main shock, has already happened.

This sounds awesome! I would love to see something like this (assuming that death isn’t involved). I lived in Iceland for a while and was so ready for an eruption (we had our plan all worked out), but of course it didn’t happen until well after I left. Maybe someday…

I tend to agree with you on the general principle and possibility for predicting significant quakes, and reaffirm that Taiwan makes for an very good seismic laboratory, aside from all the complications associated with three tectonic plates colliding in the same location. I’ve been doing my amateur geologist thing for awhile now, and I feel there has to be a pattern to be found in what’s happening here, and perhaps one that can be applied to other areas on Earth. However, I am not a walking super-computer, and the factors/indicators are so many and so diversified that it makes it difficult to assign “risk” based on only one or two of them. Fortunately, there is a wealth of data being generated hereabouts, and that may lead to formulating a model. One must bear in mind that models for even ONE fault in Taiwan are not likely to be universally applied to others, even if they are nearby. The ocean area just off the Su-Hua Hwy appears to me to be a good place to start with a model, as there are a sufficient number of larger (5+) quakes there so as to confirm validity. Perhaps a summation of energies released over time along individual fault lines will show there is a correlation between some of them, e.g, “Once the energy total released near Pingtung, plus a factor of the energy released over in Taichung, minus a factor of the energy released along the Su-Hua area exceeds a certain limit, then a larger quake in Su-Hua might be expected.” Something like that.

Allow me to quote myself.

Here is what I said on 6/18:

And here is what happened the very next day:
6/19, 01:49, 34.9 km SSW of Hualian, 3.8

I have The GIFT! :astonished:

Oh really? That prognostication was NOTHING!

“The gift” was to predict the two quakes, one in Pingtung and one off of Yilan that happened yesterday. Check my prediction and the record! :laughing:
(Granted, I thought they’d both be closer to a 5…)

As for mid Hualien County, it’s still rolling steadily… now up over 90 medium quakes in the past few days. I still don’t understand what’s up with that.

I’ll go out on limb and say, Nantou gets a 4+ within a week, once Pingtung and Yilan shift a little more.

Nothing?

NOTHING?!
:no-no:

I predicted a quake to occur soon; it happened 14 hours later less than a city block from where I said.

And you say that’s nothing. :loco: :noway: :liar: :aiyo: :unamused: :hand:

I
have THE GIFT! You have that year-old fruitcake that Gramma gave to Mom and she forgot about after taking up freezer space until your sad birthday rolled around.

Ok guys, I’d prefer this thread isn’t shut down because of this… The topic was should Taiwan create an earthquake prediction center… not a thread to make predictions regardless is real or not. :smiley:

I predict there will be a 3-4.5m quake SOMEWHERE in Taiwan today.

But seriously, something like Japan’s early warning system (which isn’t a prediction, but a “get the fuck under a table your shit is going to get fucked up in 5 seconds” kind of thing) would be a good idea:

HAHAHA.
Reminds me of the Cold War days in the 60s when the alarm siren would wail, and the teacher would shout out the orders: “Crawl under your desk! Put your head between your knees! GOOD! Now… kiss your ass goodbye!”

Regarding predictions, may I remind you -and inform the newbies- of Professor Wang, the guy who predicted a quake that would split the island in two and swindled a lot of money from his followerrs when they bought a lot of containers as shelters and set them in nantou -of all places? Remember that one?

Yeah – I thought about that a few times during the course of this thread. Major earthquake prediction, excluding aftershocks, is impossible right now. Warning systems on the other hand should be further developed, I think: at least there should be an alarm system that everyone knows about…

I hadn’t heard of that one. Fascinating!
Soooo, if I may I ask…
Which half of the island did you put YOUR shelter on? :laughing:

Wasn’t that just a year or two? I seem to recall that he did actually sell some of his containers and a few newscasts of angry people demanding their money back and being threatening toward the news crews. Were there any follow-up stories? What happened to the guy?

That guy is an idiot. It is these sorts of people who make the rest of the public weary that prediction is possible. There was no basis for his prediction other than play on people’s fears and to make financial gains from his prediction to get people to buy containers from him and from some other sources, at least this is what I heard. He was fined by the government, but very little happened to him as far I know. Predictions of this sort from people like him are bad, simply bad, there was no basis at all for his prediction. He predicted a magnitude 14 to strike central Taiwan. Indeed a 14 is possible but one hasn’t happen for like 15,000 years, but I forget exactly, you can check wikipedia like I did last year to check to see if this was even possible. Indeed it is, but honestly very very unlikely to occur within our lifetime. Regardless, this guy used fear to get money because he made this prediction just after the 3-11 quake in Japan. So people fell into his trap. Indeed there are people who you should and should not listen to when it comes to this sort of stuff at all. He is certainly someone you should ignore.

Last we heard was he was teaching in some university. :laughing:

edit:
where’s that thread? we had discussed about him. real money grubber, pity the law did not squash him like a bug

EDIT: Ah, here: forumosa.com/taiwan/viewtopic.php?t=96164

Earthquake prediction is still very much a search of the Holy Grail.

Taiwan has laws against prediction because of the propensity of some to use false, unscientific predictions to incite civil unrest .

Thread revival..!
Some gossip about a big quake becoming more likely. Plus the Japanese map which illustrated risk along its south east region.
So anyway - how would society in Taiwan prepare and respond to a huge quake?

We in Calif have people telling us a quake of a magnitude of 9 is possible any minute to many decades from now

Life goes on

Most of us are not going to die from a quake

There are many clear and present dangers to be aware of

Taiwan loses several thousand people a year to traffic accidents

The percentage of people who died in quakes over the last hundred years say is small compared to those who died from just traffic

So worry but don’t be too worried

There is not a whole lot you can do

Is this the quake from anime Nostradamus?

You guys are quite late to this party. It has been a worldwide internet sensation for quite a while.

This has been the latest video I’ve seen on the subject: a computer simulation of the effects of an 8.1 quake and tsunami, with some expert’s thoughts on how it wouldn’t be possible. Instead he offers an alternative: since the vision only encompasses a tsunami, then it must be a meteor falling on Earth and affecting all Japan, Taiwan, Philippines and Hong Kong.

Again, several reputable experts have been on tv explaining the physical and geological impossibility of anything remotely like the manga happening.

Personally, I think it is more likely a metaphor for some kind of war/weapon, as she saw two dragons fighting and then the tsunami.

Then I wonder why I can’t fall asleep…