Hi all, please find below my timeline for my application which unfortunately has not yet been approved. I submitted my case 4,5 months ago and my case is now considered a âcross-industry caseâ which got a bit stuck.
I work at a big4 company with >8 years experience in consultancy and I meet the salary requirement.
Timeline:
29 December 2020: application submitted under âEconomyâ (salary criteria). Payslips and tax assessments submitted (back then no additional proof for industry required).
8 January 2021: Professional Review by Workforce Development Agency
21 February 2021: Request for additional documents to proof industry and received advice from Workforce Development agency to change to âFinanceâ because I work for a big four company.
22 February 2021: Changed industry to âFinanceâ and submitted additional documents such as employment certificates, additional explanations about industry etc.
7 April 2021: Contacted by Finance department explaining that âFinanceâ is only for financial institutes, not for accounting firms and definitely not for consulting roles.
22 April 2021: System (finally) opened and I changed category to âEconomyâ (Salary) and submitted additional documents to support economy industry.
11 May 2021: Called the workforce development agency to check status and was informed that Economy department suggested to change to Finance. The Workforce Development Agency (and the Helpdesk) suggested to try again via e.g. experience subcategory within âEconomyâ.
Next steps and request for help:
At this moment Iâm waiting for the system to open again. Do you think it would make sense to apply under a different subcategory (Experience instead of Salary)? Would the result really be different if the issue is not related to my salary?
Maybe to avoid the âbig crowdâ applying under the salary category of Economy at least the turnaround time may be quicker?
Do you have any suggestions on how to make case for Economy industry (Consulting) stronger with specific documents/explanations? Iâm planning to add the earlier shared list of sectors for Economy, which also shows that Management Consulting falls under Economy.
Anything else that could help?
I have already submitted all the documents that are listed, even if they were optional (payslips, tax documents, employment contract, employment certificate, explanations including a translation in Chinese etc.).
I have to say that the contact person of the Workforce Development Agency and the Helpdesk have been very friendly. They can only give some advice, but they cannot challenge any results from the Economy or Finance departments or provide more details regarding their decisions. Without contact details of the Economy department I find it difficult to receive more clarity on what their exact reasoning is to not approve my case or what kind of supporting information is lacking.
Does anyone maybe have a suggestion for a third party to assist with my case?
New Policy developments for âcross-industryâ cases
Perhaps relevant for others here too: the workforce development agency and the gold card helpdesk informed me that they are still working on changing the policy to have less âcross-industryâ cases like mine that may not fit into the existing criteria, . However, they canât provide any estimates on timelines for this policy change other than that it may take a while.