Toyota Prius review (finally!)

Source

Click here for pictures and a link to a Prius English information site.

Click here for the Prius Taiwan site.


The Toyota Prius hasn’t been a hit in Taiwan to say the least. Since debuting over a year ago, there have only been about 300 vehicles sold island wide, and sales are greatly flagging. With next to no advertising campaign, little environmental education or care, not much incentive for the public to purchase cleaner cars by the government, and relatively cheap fuel abound, the Prius is yet to be a consideration for many in Taiwan and the 1.2 million NT price tag is no help. To make a prius even less desirable, some diesel fueled vehicles are more economical to run, using much cheaper fuel and returning about the same number of miles/kilometers to the gallon/litre, if not more. So with all this said, why on earth did I buy a Prius?

I had looked at all kinds of cars before making my purchase and the Prius doesn’t compare to many. There are many significant differences, that for some will seem strange, yet for some like myself will seem like the vehicle it is and that is a great clean breath of fresh air; a refreshing change from the simple and mundane internal combustion engines of the last 100 years. A beacon of hope, which is lighting the way for even more daring experiments in vehicle design and development that will perhaps one day mean that we wont have to keep going on about horse power and CCs, but instead brag about how renewable our vehicle’s energy sources are and how far vehicles have come in terms of design. The Prius therefore deserves its own style of review and this is it.

Firstly I’m not going to try and compare it to another car, but cars in general. This may seem odd, but then as I explained it’s not a typical type of car.

The Cabin

The cabin of the Prius is spacious to say the least. The plastics in the cabin are of top Toyota quality and design and build have not been compromised in any area. The layout of the dashboard is made easy by the simplistic controls and read outs. Fpr example the speedometer is a digital projected display, projected just below the windscreen and there is a distinct lack of distracting dials and knobs, made tidy by the central touch screen which offers control of air conditioning elements and vents, information on fuel economy and music selections, and if adapted can offer an external view of the car through cameras and can operate itunes. The cabin offers as much leg room as a medium to large saloon car and so seating is not a problem at all, even for the tallest of drivers. The ceiling is higher than most saloon cars or hatch backs and leaves a good few inches between a six foot driver or passenger and ceiling, and the floor pan is low, giving an airy feel, as well as a good degree of comfort, made even slightly better by the reasonably supportive grey leather seats. The rear seating isn’t forgotten about either, having good leg room, comfortable seats and ISOFIX technology for the allowance of the safest and most practical child seating available. The hump in the rear floor is there, but is low, allowing reasonable space for a fifth passenger in the middle, secured by a third seat belt instead of a lap belt. Although the boot space is large, it is shallow due to batteries situated under the floor and the tail of the roof line is a slanted rear hatch, which doesn’t allow for the loading of tall objects, although the rear seats do fold flat, allowing for a very large loading space, which is much better than most four door saloons.

Extras

The Prius in Taiwan is available in only one package, and everything is standard, so there is no choice but to accept the six airbags and 5 star NCAP safety rating, cruise control, climate control, ABS, traction control, electric mirrors, single disk CD player, computer LCD centrally mounted display, steering wheel stereo and climate control buttons and electronic steering, which is a fair package of gadgets to keep most drivers happy during the most tedious driving conditions.

There are various websites in the states that are selling hacks for the in cabin display, allowing it to perform hidden functions and adapt to D.I.Y. plugin cjextras such as external cameras, ipod interfaces with itunes, which can be controlled by the touch screen display and more, perhaps for the first time making an affordable car seem like a more personable piece of equipment such as a telephone or P.C.

On the down side to the interior, the electrically adjusted mirrors do not fold in at the touch of any button and must be manually folded, and the steering wheel is only adjustable up and down, not telescopically which is a function that really should be there to accommodate differing types and sizes of driver. The Prius in some countries also comes with the option of a self parking function, which literally parks the car for the driver, incorporating the use of the electronic steering and bumper mounted radar, although the car in Taiwan cannot come with this option and may be missed by some as the rear view from the driver’s seat is largely restricted by the split rear window and thick rear pillars, made even worse by rain on the anti U.V. layer which is fitted to our car’s windows, leaving almost no rear view at all when reversing at night; quite a scary situation indeed.

Owners in Asia do however have the benefit of one option that isn’t available on all cars abroad, which is the addition of an ‘E.V.’ switch. This switch under low speed and sufficient battery charge conditions, offers full electric mode to the driver which makes for very low vehicle noise when creeping home at night. A maximum of 2 kilometers can be reached in E.V. mode under perfect conditions, but will not power the vehicle if the vehicle has run out of petrol/gas, as a fail safe kicks in and will cut the vehicle’s power.

The Drive

Even when considering the hard economy tyres and non independent rear suspension of the Prius, the ride is very good indeed, and comparable to some of the better family cars on the market. The steering is accurate and positive in corners and the car stays firm with little body roll. The electronic steering is without much feel at speed and in corners however, due to minimum driver effort, but is a bonus at low speed maneuvers, making the most difficult and tiring turns easy, even for the frailest of drivers. The front and rear disk brakes provide very sharp and positive stopping power, although take some getting used to, due to the almost full stop or no stop nature of the pedal. The tires of the Prius don’t help the noise levels at speed, which can be quite high at times, certainly when traveling concrete road surfaces. The isolative and insulation materials used on the Prius are of a minimum and of low weight, making up for the extra weight of on board batteries situated in the floor, just behind the rear seats. This means that the car, although quiet at average speeds largely depends on the type of tyres fitted to reduce the levels of road noise at speed.

The drive is most different to most cars in city and during congestion, and the Prius excels in this area. When stopped or at low speed, the car often shuts down the engine and relies on an electric motor and batteries for both propulsion and power to the electrical systems, including the air-conditioning. This gives the car almost ghost like qualities, and at these times often feels more like a space ship than a car. Pedestrians beware though, as few people hear it coming at low speed and frequently walk into its path, or walk ahead of it, totally unaware of its presence until the driver is eventually forced to either blip the horn or flash the lights, without frightening the life out of people. The single geared variable transmission also adds another odd sense to the car, which is the lack of acceleration. The car isn’t a great accelerator, but the single gear means that the vehicle never jerks from one gear to another, providing an almost constant ‘G’ all the way up to the vehicle’s top speed. This also means that flooring the accelerator gives little feeling of greater acceleration than simply driving normally, but for the high revving engine that gets noisy when driven hard, providing little incentive to drive hard, but a greater incentive to conserve more fuel and drive quietly.

Trying to explain how the hybrid system works.

The batteries of the Prius are not charged by plugging the car into a wall socket as with some electric vehicles, but are charged by the motor/converter that woks in combination with the engine, transmission and electrical circuit. When accelerating hard or climbing, the motor and engine work together, providing maximum torque in harmony with the variable gearbox, which are all computer controlled to boost and balance efficiency with maximum effort. When cruising at low speed the engine is frequently shut down and the motor does much of the work. When cruising at high speed, the engine does most of the work and the motor is often switched to charging the batteries. When stopped, the motor and engine are turned off to conserve power, and when the vehicle is slowing or descending the engine is turned off and the motor switches to converting the vehicle’s motive force into electricity to recharge the batteries. If the batteries are running too low when the vehicle is stopped, due to lights, air-conditioning and other power demanding circuits, then the engine is restarted to power the motor/converter and recharge the batteries. Everything is done automatically and the driver doesn’t have to do a thing, but steer and push either the brake or accelerator as normal.

The provision of the electrically controlled variable transmission also means that there is no need for a gear lever between the front seats and Toyota have even removed the hand brake and fitted a foot depressed parking brake, leaving the centre of the car for storage and an arm rest.

This entire system doesn’t really conserve as much fuel as Toyota claims (60+mpg), but to get close to their claims a vehicle must have to drive consistently using no accessories such as air conditioning, stereo, lights and other necessary circuits, which is to say unreasonable at the least. I found that driving realistically with air-conditioning on and other electrical systems, yet sensibly during highway driving at about 110kph, the car returned about 19km per 1 litre of fuel, mountain road driving at variable speeds returned about 24 km per litre and inner city driving returned about 16km per litre, which although sounding the least economical is probably much more economical than many internal combustion engine cars of relative size during city driving conditions.

A result of 36.7 miles per gallon city driving, 55.1miles per gallon on mountain roads and 43.6 miles per gallon on the highway. Not close to Toyotas claims by a long shot, but not too bad overall.

Summary

The Prius is not for everyone as it is not a performance car and is expensive at a list price of 1.2 million NT. In terms of power, Toyota says that it is on par with a normally aspirated 2.0 litre petrol engine family saloon in terms of acceleration, but it is very difficult indeed to compare this car in such a manner. The Prius therefore defies comparisons in terms of performance, but does excel in terms of build quality, design and function as well as expression. A driver in a Prius is making a clear statement to others, that they not only wish to drive something cleaner and more efficient, but that they wish to drive something different and that they are not afraid of the future or any great change in vehicle design. A Prius driver is not as interested in getting somewhere faster as they are interested in an idea and a concept that one day vehicles may be more individual in terms of design and propulsion, and that being cleaner does not necessarily mean we must give up all creature comforts. A Prius therefore is as much of a statement as it is an achievement, and Toyota deserve every bit of praise for daring to do what many others have been reluctant to for some time. The success of the Prius in many countries shows the want and desire for future development in cleaner cars, as well as a desire to drive something that little bit different, and that word perhaps makes for the best and most simple summary. Different!4

I’ve read several articles recently that made mention of the prius. It’s the yuppie car of the future apparently.

Good review. Interesting car.

Excellent review. The price is crazy.

Aaargh, I just wrote a lengthy post about driving (as a passenger in) a Prius over CNY in Taichung but then my browser crashed when I opened another tab to check if you’d write “run over someone” or “run someone over”. Great.

Anyhow, thanks for posting the review. Here’s a part of what I had to say:

  • The Prius got an average of 6.2l/100km (ask Google what this is in km/l or mpg) which isn’t too bad considering Taichung’s crazy traffic and the need to keep the A/C on all the time. I get around 5.3l/100km in Luxembourg and drivers in less densely populated areas can still do much better.

  • The touchscreen can’t be set to Chinese, seems they took it from the European version.

  • Many people recognize the car and ask questions, but most are visibly and understandably put off by the price.

  • Single CD player without audio-in jack sucks.

  • It doesn’t have the smooth underbody panel which improves aerodynamics at high speeds:

This makes sense, after all, how much high-speed-driving can you do before you fall off the island?

  • EV mode has additional benefits: your lazy employees won’t hear you arriving, your wife won’t hear you leaving at night and rival gangster bosses won’t notice when you’re about to run them over. Hahaha. :wink:

Anyhow, I think a true plug-in electric car with a reasonable range would be perfect for Taiwan but until then, the Prius is a great choice, too. BTW, the next generation is due for late 2008 / early 2009 (in Japan).

I have read that the next generation Prius might be a diesel car, so I’ll be happy if they can make it as clean as the present model, as that will be a great step for diesels and might see many more petrol engines retired. Yes, the 1.2 million price tag is a bit mad, but when you compare the technology, safety, and build quality, you will find that no island built car can match it and only other imports offer anything close to it. The 1.2 million is also a bit of an unrealistic price too as at least 80,000 can be knocked off the price of a new Prius. We knocked 200,000nt off ours as it is a 2006 built car, although the same spec as a 2007, so I didn’t care at all.

here in the bay area the prius is a car thats still got a waiting list and often sells for more then the MSRP Manufacturers suggested retail price.

its quite a fast car. I am often passed on the freeway even when going 130kph in my ACURA RSX by those little *uckers !!

they look dorky but are very fast and roomy and dare i say it? even fun to drive.

they cost around 22,000 usd here or so, and then you need to add bout ten pct for tax and license so round 25,000 usd. so they aint cheap!

here in the bay area the prius is a car thats still got a waiting list and often sells for more then the MSRP Manufacturers suggested retail price.

its quite a fast car. I am often passed on the freeway even when going 130kph in my ACURA RSX by those little *uckers !!

they look dorky but are very fast and roomy and dare i say it? even fun to drive.

they cost around 22,000 usd here or so, and then you need to add bout ten pct for tax and license so round 25,000 usd. so they aint cheap!

[/quote]

I formerly typed discounts of 800,000, when it should have read 80,000, sorry about that.

I have heard from a friend who’s sister produces a motoring magazine in the States that there are waiting lists of up to two years in the States. Has anyone else heard of this?

I’ve heard mention before of the JDM prius having automated parking or somesuch thing… any fact in this?

The Prius is a car I would consider for it’s economy as a daily driver in Taiwan’s cities… apart from that price… didn’t realise they’re so pricey… ridiculous!

A few updates on the Prius since I purchased it.

The sound system has some whopping loud speakers in it, but I had a slight rattle in the passenger door due to the minimal soundproofing and large speakers fitted. I solved the problem with a peice of 3m wall sticker stuck between the window switch panel and the door panel.

I have the most horid smell of mould coming from the air ducts when I first start the car in the morning. I returned the car to Toyota and those bumblers told me it must be the air freshener corroding the plastics. They asked me to try it without any air freshener in the car and to not use the air recycling cycle which would add to the humidity (eyes rolling, yeah right!) Anyway I couldn’t believe they were trying to tell me it was the air freshener’s fault and mine for not using the through air. I couldn’t refute their claims however as they wouldn’t believe me so I took the car away for a few days then called them back to tell them nothing had changed, so now I am taking it back again tomorrow. Has anyone ever had this mould smell problem in Taiwan? It’s a first for me.

The car still drives brilliantly and is very satisfying over all. I have learned to deal with the rear visibility issue and now parking is no problem. The tyres have great grip and are slightly quieter now they are run in and I played with the pressure, increasing it by a few P.S.I. over the recomendations, both front and rear. It’s true that the recomended pressure is way too soft.

The car gets quite a lot of attention and lots of people want to know how it works and why I don’t have to charge it up from the mains.
The fuel economy changes a lot depending on my mood. I have found myself accelerating faster than when running it in and this kills the economy. Yesterday I drove it as I would any other car and it was reporting an average 7.0 litres per hundred kilometres, which is not that good, but today I reset it and began driving smoothly and slowly, always on the speed limit all around town and it reports less than 6.0 litres per hundred kilometres. It seems much of the economics come down to driver and road and slight speed increases affect the overall economy greatly.

So far I still like the car very much but am unimpressed with the quality for the money. It’s better quality than many other cars, but considering I drove a Suzuki Solio for over three years without a single glitch or problem, I can’t rate it all that well by comparison. It’s a new type of car altogether though, and I hope Toyota can address the problems over time. Considering it’s altogether new design, it’s not really that bad.

Hmm. This is a car that I really wanted to like and I know this line has been done to death but… jesus, the price tag!

Doing some number crunching I work out that you’re getting 39.3mpg from careful driving and 33.6mph from normal stop ‘n’ go. That’s pretty good, but considering that the whole point of this car and its high price is an economical, high-tech ride, I personally think they failed spectacularly on the economy point.

If I drive my old 3.2L SUV carefully in the city I get nearly 20mpg - about half your fuel economy. If I drive 10,000 miles per year I’ll be paying around NT$50k/year in fuel - you’ll be nearer the NT$25k mark. But on day-to-day commutes I ride a bike that gets way over 40mpg and use the truck for things that a Prius just can’t do (like a few weeks back when I towed a blue truck out of a ditch). And ask joesax how much stuff you can fit in a Rodeo.

But that’s an SUV… look at something like the Suzuki Swift - quoted economy of 7.3l/100km and a price tag of under NT$500,000. I’ve driven the Swift, I think they’re great little cars and given their size would bet that performance is on a very close par with the Prius, but then I haven’t driven a Prius so I shouldn’t really be making any comparisons.

I have to say though, even though I would never even think about buying a Prius at that price I always smile on the rare occasion I see one around Taichung. There is something feel-good about them, isn’t there?

[quote=“llary”]And ask joesax how much stuff you can fit in a Rodeo.[/quote]A lot! All my wordly goods (at least all the ones worth keeping). Much appreciated.

I think there’s a hybrid SUV either being produced already or about to be produced. Not a bad idea at all though I guess it’s aimed at “soccer mums” rather than serious off-roaders.

Just to correct the point here. The car was designed to be the cleanest in terms of exhaust emisions and not the most economical. Don’t purchase this car for economy, as there are better cars out there like the VW Lupo or Fox as it is now called. Yes, a motorcycle should always be better for economy, and a Swift, Yaris, Civic will all be better when cost per kilometer are worked out. It is not a cheap car and we didn’t purchase it for its economy, but for the size, safety, quality, economy, and overal difference of driving. I’ve driven all types of cars, but I can still say that this one is the most different I have driven.

Right. Now I am warming myself up for tomorrow’s shouting match if they give me some other brown mouthed excuse for the car smelling like ol socks when I start it up. I’m going to tell them that there isn’t anything in the instruction manual about smelling like old fart because of either improper usage of the air vents or air fresheners corroding the plastics. My word what will they think of next? If they won’t fix it I’m going to ask them if they would like to pay me by the hour to fix my own car.

[quote=“sulavaca”]Just to recorrect the point here. The car was designed to be the cleanest in terms of exhaust emisions and not the most economical. Don’t purchase this car for economy, as there are better cars out there like the VW Lupo or Fox as it is now called. Yes, a motorcycle should always be better for economy, and a Swift, Yaris, Civic will all be better when cost per kilometer are worked out. It is not a cheap car and we didn’t purchase it for its economy, but for the size, safety, quality, economy, and overal difference of driving. I’ve driven all types of cars, but I can still say that this one is the most different I have driven.

Right. Now I am warming myself up for tomorrow’s shouting match if they give me some other brown mouthed excuse for the car smelling like ol socks when I start it up. I’m going to tell them that there isn’t anything in the instruction manual about smelling like old fart because of either improper usage of the air vents or air fresheners corroding the plastics. My word what will they think of next? If they won’t fix it I’m going to ask them if they would like to pay me by the hour to fix my own car.[/quote]

I see your point, and like I said I do feel good about the fact that there are Taiwanese out there thinking along the same lines. I would love to have a chance to drive one - I just know I won’t be taking it home with me at NT$1.2m.

PS - I mentioned you and your Prius today in conversation with some salesman prick boasting about having spent NT$4m on his Lexus. I pointed out that given everyone who wants to be someone in Taiwan has already had the same idea, he could have blown a quarter of that on something truly unique like your Prius and spent the rest on a ten year supply of cheesy suits and Brylcream.

[quote=“llary”]
PS - I mentioned you and your Prius today in conversation with some salesman prick boasting about having spent NT$4m on his Lexus. I pointed out that given everyone who wants to be someone in Taiwan has already had the same idea, he could have blown a quarter of that on something truly unique like your Prius and spent the rest on a ten year supply of cheesy suits and Brylcream.[/quote]

LOL! Yes, I think the same too. I thought Mini? Well they are tiny, more expensive than a Prius and everyone with a huge credit card bill has one. Lexus? Every business man in Taiwan has one if he hasn’t already got a Merc or B.M.W. The Prius is just a bit different that’s all. I do like Lexus, but they are practically common place here.

[quote=“joesax”][quote=“llary”]And ask joesax how much stuff you can fit in a Rodeo.[/quote]A lot! All my wordly goods (at least all the ones worth keeping). Much appreciated.

I think there’s a hybrid SUV either being produced already or about to be produced. Not a bad idea at all though I guess it’s aimed at “soccer mums” rather than serious off-roaders.[/quote]

My sister has one…A Lexus 400. A very stealthy and powerful soccer mom vehicle. Build quality, ride and power are superb. It’s damn fast for a hybrid.

I’m still waiting for a 4x4 with independent electric motors on every wheel…Could you imagine the torgue possibilities for wheeling? Whoa.

There is a hybrid Ford Escape in Taiwan apparantly, although I don’t think I would have seen one.

I got the car back last night from Toyota and the smell has been completely cleared with some cleaning solution having been applied to both the radiator and cooler venting. A different technician still believes that the smell is caused by some strange combination of plastics combined with the new friendly plastics of the car. He has removed my rubber floor mats and put my carpet pile mats in the car to see if it eliminates the smell. We will see, but I’m happy for now.
In fact I would recommend anyone having the air system cleaned with this medical solution, it gets rid of any smell at all. Well worth it on a car of age or an ex smoker’s car. My interior was also treated with a carbon cleaning compound to remove any odor from the interior panels and seats etc. It’s just like it was when new now with absolutely no odor of any kind. Brilliant!

Moldy or musty smell from the a/c might mean your evaporator box have mildew in it. Remember to turn off your re-circulation switch when you park your car to prevent mildew growth.

If the smell is coming from the vent, clean it with a damp cotton swaps, then blast the heat for 10 min to dry it out.

My father has one…it’s an amazing car that’s a joy to drive. My main complaint is the relatively large blind spots on the left and right of the windshield, increasing the possibility of hitting a pedestrian who’s crossing at an intersection when you’re making a right turn.

During my recent visit to the Bay Area I saw an amazing number of Prii (often four on the same block), but I saw very few when visiting the Midwest (Cedar Rapids, Louisville and St. Louis) - only six the entire week of my travels there.