(Last edited 2023/10/26 according to other Forumosans’ input in the thread below)
Yes I searched, and I found lots of questions about which one is better - but the discussions after those questions didn’t really go much into the advantages or disadvantages of either. I am now wondering which one to choose (or maybe a “gold card” in case one is eligible). My case is: German citizen, just married, spouse is ROC national, I’m in Taiwan since 2.5 years on a work ARC (and before 3 years work ARC from 2008, in between working in Germany with no ARC). Plus, I’m generally wondering if I could somehow get my ageing retired parents here permanently to take better care of them personally.
Here is my current understanding of the advantages and disadvantages of different ARCs and APRC:
1. Work Permit:
Marriage ARC: Don’t need a work permit (can change employers, have multiple employers, have own business, …)
Work ARC: Employer needs to apply a work permit for you. You can only work for the employer and at the place stated on the ARC (Possibly can also work for others in parallel, maybe with or without additional permits).
Note: If you are married to an ROC national, then you don’t need a work permit.
Gold Card ARC: open work permit (similar effect to being married to an ROC national)
2. Applying for APRC after X years
Marriage ARC to Marriage APRC: can apply for APRC after 5 years residency (183 days/year) out of the last 10 years (arbitrary, not necessary continuous - as long as you had residency eg. an ARC during the whole time). APRC is always permanent, you can keep it even after divorce.
Work ARC to Work APRC: Can apply after 5 years continuous residency (183 days/year)
Gold Card ARC to gold card APRC: Can apply after 5 years continuous residency (183 days/year). According to @irish91 there might be plans to allow APRC application already after 3 years residency.
Notes:
- you can only apply for the APRC type according to your current ARC. So if you for example have a work ARC and want a marriage APRC, you first need to change your ARC to a marriage based one.
- According to information I got from NIA, changing ARC types between marriage, work and gold card ARCs does NOT reset the timer for the residency, as long as there are no gaps in between (ARC expiry or having a different ARC like Student ARC or Blue collar work ARC).
3. APRC vs. staying outside Taiwan
Marriage APRC: Need to stay 183 days per year in Taiwan (can stay away up to 2 years if you apply first)
Work APRC: need to return to TW once in 5 years
Gold Card APRC: need to return to TW once in 5 years [1]
4. National Health Insurance - NHI
Marriage ARC: After 6 months you can enroll through your spouse, or immediately if you have an employer
Work ARC: Enrolled in NHI through employer
Gold Card ARC: After 6 months you can enroll on your own, or immediately if you have an employer (note: there seems to be a new law on the way where the 6 months period is waived for gold card holders without an employer)
5. Pension
Marriage ARC: yes, due to being married to an ROC citizen (Thanks, @tando)
Work ARC: only when married to an ROC citizen, or work APRC (Thanks, @tando)
Gold Card ARC: only when married to an ROC citizen, or Gold Card APRC (Thanks, @tando)
6. Employment Insurance
Employment insurance is only if married to an ROC citizen
7. Can foreign parents join the ARC holder in Taiwan permanently
Marriage ARC: No
Work ARC: No
Gold Card ARC: Not permanently, but for longer at a time than other ARCs
8. Validity
Marriage ARC: first 1 year, then can chose 1, 2 or 3 years for renewal
Work ARC: first up to 3 years (depending on contract - thanks @tando), then 3 years if keeping same job (experience of @squall1)
Note: The first work ARC of foreign special professionals (those who would qualify for the gold card ARC) can be for 5 years
Gold Card ARC: Can chose 1, 2 or 3 years at application
9. Extension in case of ARC reason gone
Marriage ARC: No extension possible if divorced
Work ARC: If quitting job or having been fired, you can extend for 6 months while looking for a new job. Can also extend a 2nd time, for a total of 12 months.
Gold Card ARC: Not extendable, need to apply again for a new gold card ARC and then be judged if you still meet the criteria