2020 : My journey towards getting Taiwanese Citizenship for myself and my infant daughter

Given my immense luck with Taiwanese authorities in general, I thought I should record my entire experience towards gaining Taiwanese citizenship with my fellow Forumosans. Perhaps this will help someone who is planning to do the same in the near future.

My current status :

  1. I’ve worked in Taiwan for 6 years (the last 3 were on a Gold Card).
  2. My daughter was born in Taiwan. She is 1 year old (+ 2 months).
  3. My wife is a Filipino, and so is my daughter. I am the only one with …ahem… Pakistani citizenship.
  • I plan to apply for citizenship for myself via the “Voluntary Naturalization” (自願歸化) route.
  • For my daughter, I will apply via the “Unmarried minor children of the naturalized person shall apply for accompanying naturalization.” (歸化人之未婚未成年子女,申請隨同歸化。) route.

For the official list of requirements, you can get them at the following links :

Below are direct links to the official documents from the MOI website that are related to the naturalization route that I am taking :

List of Requirements (Chinese Version)

List of Requirements (English Version)

Application Forms (Dual Language) :

If the list of requirements from the MOI website seems confusing, I have a made a more simpler list of requirements to serve as a checklist for me & my daughter. You can download it here.

Right off the bat, the first thing that complicates the situation is the fact that the person applying for naturalization and the accompanying minor child are actually citizens of two different countries. Thankfully though, so far there’s no indication that this will be a problem.

Since my journey already started in Nov, 2019, here’s what I have done so far :

Chapters of my journey so far :

A. ////Failure to start - Childbirth Issues/////

  • I completed my 5 years of work in Taiwan in Nov, 2019. Just 2 weeks prior to my qualification my daughter was born. Unfortunately, she suffered from a broken clavicle + displaced hips (that I believe was due to improper labor/delivery by the hospital). I have a whole post dedicated to that, if you are interested. Needless to say, I had to put all my efforts towards my daughter and my application got delayed by a few months.

B. ////Failure to start - Father’s Illness/////

  • By January 2020, my daughter was already on her track to recovery and I was ready to work on my citizenship application. Unfortunately, my father’s last living family member (his older brother) died thousands of miles away in another country. My father screamed and cried for an entire week. Ended up suffering multiple strokes. He got vascular dementia (later diagnosed in Taiwan). Vascular dementia is “dementia + Alzheimer” caused suddenly due to stroke/s. He lost his memory and couldn’t even recognize his own kids. He couldn’t even recall our names. He couldn’t even find his way around the house anymore.

To understand why my father had such a severe reaction to news of his brother passing away, jump to the end of the post to read a brief story (that I have never shared publicly) about his tragic life and his special connection to his older brother.

  • On hearing about my father’s worsening condition, I gave up my citizenship process and decided to bring him to Taiwan for treatment. Since my father was now unfit to travel himself, first I had to go to Dubai (twice) to get a Taiwanese visa for my father. Gold Card ARC holder’s parents qualify for 1 year visa, but TECO Dubai wouldn’t agree, and even after getting direct emails from NDC + BOCA Taipei to support me (following my complaints), TECO Dubai still gave my father only a 3-month visa. This was later corrected in Taiwan, along with an apology from BOCA. After securing his visa, I traveled to Pakistan and brought him back in a wheelchair to Taiwan (which was hard for me, to see him like that).

C. ////COVID Problems - Lockdowns/////

  • It was now March, 2020, and Coronavirus was getting worse by the day. After speaking to HHRO they told me I needed to prepare 3 things before I could do anything :
  1. Pass the Chinese exam (or take 200 hours of lessons)
  2. Get a police clearance certificate from my country
  3. Get a single (unmarried) certificate for my daughter (who was 5 months old at the time)
  • I decided to delay the Chinese exam (given my zero Chinese skills) and prepare the documents first. At first I butted heads with the Ministry of Interior to challenge their requirement of a “single certificate” for an infant, especially one that was born in Taiwan (and had never left Taiwan). Sadly, they insisted, and I failed to convince them. If you want to read my correspondence with them, you can find it at the end of the post.

  • Given that my daughter is a Filipino citizen, we had to hire an agent in Manila to get her documents. For myself, given the fact that the “designated TECO for Pakistani’s is TECRO Saudi” so that’s where I had to get my police clearance authenticated.

  • Both Pakistan, Philippines and Saudi had lockdowns which lasted weeks and months. Getting the documents (which would normally take a week) took several months. Then things got further delayed at the respective TECO offices (which were often closed). By the time my police clearance was authenticated by TECO, it was already 6 months from the date of issue and was invalid. My daughter’s single certificate got expired before it ever got the Taiwanese authentication. It was August now. After wasting nearly 60,000NT$ paying agents, embassy fees, and DHL fees, I had to restart the whole process again.

  • But before I could restart, I had to take a month off to return my father back to Pakistan. He said he didn’t want to die in Taiwan and wanted to return home. As he was still unable to travel alone, I took a leave and accompanied him back to Pakistan in August. On return I had to spend 14 days in Quarantine + 7 days of self-management.

  • In the meantime, I restarted preparation of the two documents that I needed. As of now (Dec, 25th), my police clearance document is ready and in my hands (but already 4 months past its issuance date). My daughters document is still stuck in Manila at TECO and should be done before end of January.

D. ////Chinese Language Exam/////

Unfortunately, my Chinese is crap and having already lost a year, I decided not to spend 3 to 6 months to take 200 hours of Chinese lessons (especially on top of my full-time job). Instead, I have been working on and off on version 2 of the “Cracking the Naturalization Exam” based on the new 252 questions. I have somewhat completed the crack, but it’s not polished enough for publishing here (I will do it soon). I am preparing for the exam now (on and off - due to busy work schedule) and will get it done soon.


|| CURRENT STATUS ||| ==>> I plan to go for my first-attempt next week. If I succeed, I hope to submit our applications for citizenship at the same time. <<==


------Extra-stuff ---------

////My Correspondence with Ministry of Interior regarding requirement of a single certificate for a 6-month-old baby/////

------My first email to Ministry of Interior :

  • Hi, I am a foreign national, also a Taiwan Gold Card ARC holder. I have already been working in Taiwan for over 5 and half years. I don’t have a Taiwanese spouse. I am planning to apply for voluntary naturalization next month. I have a 6-month-old daughter. She was born in Taiwan and has never left Taiwan. I plan to apply for my baby’s “accompanying naturalization” as well. The only problem I have is with the requirement of: * a) Police Clearance Certificate * b) Single (No Marriage) Certificate
  • The first one, luckily it can be exempted, but there is no mention of exemption for the 2nd requirement. Just to let you know, I visited xxxx Household Registration Office, because I plan to apply there, and they insisted that I needed to get a “single certificate” for the baby.
  • Is it really appropriate to require a “Single/No marriage Certificate” for a 6-month baby? I would kindly ask that you reconsider your 2nd requirement and add an exception to it as well, especially for “infants/babies”. It’s just too uncomfortable, even the idea of having to get such a certificate for an infant.
  • I hope to hear from you soon. Thank you for your consideration.

------Their response :

  • 詢問未成年子女申請隨同歸化是否須繳附婚姻狀況證明1案,茲答復如下:
  • 一、依據您信中提及,您的女兒目前6個月大,預計於下個月隨同您申請歸化我國國籍,女兒申請歸化是否須繳付婚姻狀況證明。按國籍法第7條規定:「歸化人之未婚未成年子女,得申請隨同歸化。」;另按同法施行細則第8條第1項第5款規定:「未婚未成年人附繳其法定代理人同意證明及其婚姻狀況證明。但經外交部查證因原屬國法律或行政程序限制,致使不能提出婚姻狀況證明屬實者,免附。」
  • 二、按國籍法施行細則第8條第1項第5款規定意旨,係為舉證當事人為「未婚」,始得適用寬鬆歸化國籍規定,俾與父母共同生活。鑑於各國法定結婚最低年齡不同,且有些國家無結婚最低年齡限制,為符合國籍法規定意旨,不宜就應提憑婚姻狀況證明之最低年齡為一致性規定。惟考量實務上,當事人原屬國有因未成年人尚未達該國結婚法定年齡,故無從核發婚姻狀況證明文件之情事,爰此,如經外交部查證屬實當事人之原屬國不核發婚姻狀況證明,且當事人舉證其年齡未達原屬國之法定最低結婚年齡,始得同意其免附婚姻狀況證明文件辦理歸化。
  • 三、以上答復,希望能有助於解決您的問題,您若仍有其他疑問或不明瞭之處,歡迎隨時來電洽詢,感謝您再次的來信。

------ My 2nd Email to them :

  • 感謝您的來信和解釋。我了解您的原因。我的女兒是菲律賓人,在台灣出生,從未離開過台灣。我可以將她的ARC副本發送給您,但不確定如何發送。
  • 在菲律賓,法定結婚年齡為18歲。我向菲律賓政府發送了一封電子郵件,詢問他們有關1歲以下兒童的“單身/未婚證書”,但他們沒有回答我。
  • 我能在網上找到的唯一證據是2018年的菲律賓法律,該法律明確規定可結婚年齡為18歲,任何18歲以下的婚姻都是非法的,被視為虐待兒童。 (如果您可以訪問上面的鏈接,請閱讀第32至35行。)
  • http://www.congress.gov.ph/legisdocs/basic_17/HB08440.pdf
  • 您能否檢查這是否足夠的證據?如果是這樣,我的女兒可以免除提供“單身/未婚證書”嗎?
  • 謝謝,親切的問候
  • 注意:我想打電話給賴怡涵女士,但我很猶豫,因為我的中文很差。我用谷歌翻譯寫這個。

------ Their final response :

  • 詢問菲律賓籍子女申請隨同歸化是否須繳附婚姻狀況證明1案,茲答復如下:
  • 一、有關菲律賓未成年人申請歸化附繳婚姻狀況證明情形,依據駐菲律賓代表處105年3月3日菲領字第10501701820號函查復略以,有關未達法定結婚年齡者,菲國政府有無核發婚姻狀況證明1節,經洽菲律賓國家統計署(Philippine Statistic Authority, PSA)主任Editha R. Orcilla獲告以,倘申請人向該署提出申請並繳付相關費用,該署即可核發申請人之婚姻狀況證明。
  • 二、爰請您向菲律賓國家統計署申請您女兒的婚姻狀況證明,並依國籍法施行細則第18條規定,將該證明辦理駐外館處驗證及外交部複驗後,備妥相關證明文件再向居留地戶政事務所申請歸化國籍。
  • 三、以上答復,希望能有助於解決您的問題,您若仍有其他疑問或不明瞭之處,歡迎隨時來電洽詢,感謝您再次的來信。

////My father and his brother/////

  • My father was born in small and impoverished city of modern-day Pakistan in 1947. His mother (my grandmother) died while giving birth to him. His father (my grandfather) was upset didn’t want anything to do with the baby afterwards.
  • As long as my grandfather lived, he always told my father that he (my father i.e.) was responsible for the death of his mother.
  • My grandfather had a teenage daughter from a previous marriage. She took my father in (who was 1 day old) and decided to raise him. My father’s stepsister was unsuccessful in getting married when the time came (due to losing an eye in a freak accident). So, beyond the first few years, she was helpless and was unable to continue to care for my father. That’s where his older brother (the uncle) stepped in.
  • My uncle was just 4 years older than my father and he also had no mother, but he put it on himself to raise his little brother. He fed my father, helped him in illness, ironed his clothes, packed his bag, helped him with homework, protected him from bullies etc.
  • In 1947, the year of my father’s birth, British Raj left the Indian Subcontinent, splitting it into India & Pakistan. There was a lot of bloodshed on both sides and many lost a lot of things. My grandfather lost all his assets, which left the family in abject poverty, now having to live on <10$ a month.
  • That meant everyone had to work, including the children. Since the age of 5 my father spent his entire childhood doing hard labor all night long.
  • His labor included washing clothes of hundreds of army men, out in the open, sometimes in the crushing winter cold. Meanwhile simultaneously burning his hands in the boiling water as he rinsed them. This was followed by ironing all the clothes with an iron that was so big and heavy, he needed two hands to lift it. Lastly, folding all the clothes and carrying them on his back from one location to another.
  • That was just his nights. During the day he went to a govt. school (run by the army) where everyone from the teachers to the principal didn’t miss a chance to insult him / beat him / or bully him since he was that poor kid who washed clothes of everyone else’s fathers. His teachers would often bring their own dirty laundry to the school and have my father carry them back to his home from school for free washing. This was difficult as he had to walk 3 miles to the house, and it would often be very heavy. My uncle would take turns and together they would take them back home. They would often get beaten if they refused to take the teacher’s laundry. My grandfather took the teachers side always.
  • This is how he spent most of his days and the nights during childhood. The little bit of rest time he had in between was composed of occasionally having no food or little food, e.g. entire family sharing a single loaf of bread or drinking soup water.
  • My grandfather who was exceptionally harsh towards my father, added additional beatings on top, usually over little things. My grandfather’s favorite punishment (after he got tired of spanking) was putting my father’s hands under the feet of the bed and then going to sleep on the bed, while he cried in pain for hours.
  • They had no electricity or water. Every morning someone had to get buckets of water from a far away public tap. No electricity meant doing your homework under street light, again some distance away from the house.
  • My uncle, who also suffered a similarly difficult life, somehow ran away to another city eventually becoming a successful English teacher. He helped pave the way for his little brother. This was a trend through their lives. The older brother was always ahead and he always brother his little brother along so he too could have a better life.
  • My uncle, who as far as Pakistani standards of “beauty” go, was good looking given his fair skin and light hair, was able to attract a wealthy girl from an elite family in the big city. They fell in love with each other and decided to marry.
  • She accepted my uncle but it was conditional love. She didn’t want anything to do with his poor family and poor little brother, as they would make her look bad in “high society”. For reasons unknown to me, my uncle accepted her conditions. I don’t know if he was scared of her or not, but he usually did everything she demanded.
  • Soon after (now in the 80s) my uncle and his wife moved to Yemen (which was not a bad place back then). He began his English teaching career there and became very successful. My uncle (against the wishes of his wife) secretly got my father a visa and a job in Yemen. Now both brothers were teaching English in Yemen. They still met secretly as the wife still forbade my uncle from keeping any relationship with his little brother.
  • This lifestyle continued for 20 years, and in the meantime my grandfather passed away, and so did my father’s stepsister (who raised him in infancy). She died alone in her 60s, nearly blind. My father was heartbroken because he never could fulfill his promise of giving her a better life. Even in Yemen, my father was relatively poor and couldn’t afford to give a decent life to his sister back home.
  • Now my father had only one person left from his original family, his one and only brother. They continued to meet secretly. As a child growing up in Yemen, I was in some of those secret meetings in the 2000s. It was just a lot reminiscing, hugging, kissing and tears. My uncle would take my father in to his arms as if my he was a little kid, and kiss him on the forehead and together they would cry. This continued even as both grew old and gray.
  • In 2006, I starting working and took over all the expenses of our family. In 2010 my father was forced to retire due to the eruption of a civil war in Yemen. He left Yemen and moved back to home, while I moved to China.
  • My uncle who still feared his wife lied to my father that he would soon join him back home, but that never happened. This makes 2010, the last time they ever met in person.
  • From 2010 ~ 2012, (now thousands of miles away) they two brothers communicated by letters. My uncle was forbidden to have a cell phone. My father bought a phone and had it shipped it to my uncles work place in Yemen. The first phone was caught and confiscated by the wife. Later we sent another one. Both started with phone calls once a month (as it was expensive). Since both countries had poor communications infrastructure, internet communication wasn’t an option until much later. Only after 2017 they were finally able to do video chat from time to time on whatsapp. My father, although younger and already retired, was in much poorer health than my uncle who continued to work (& was now as a successful school principal).
  • My father begged my uncle to return home to meet him, just once before death. My father himself couldn’t travel to Yemen because all airports had been closed for years (due to the ongoing war there).
  • By this point somehow my uncle and his wife were living a life of relative luxury in Yemen (despite the civil war). At some point, my uncle’s wife and kids moved to Dubai, but left him in Yemen to keep working alone.
  • My uncle who was 74 had now been living alone for 3 years in Yemen (something we didn’t know until after his death). Also, we didn’t know that he would take a bus (as airports had been closed for years) and go to Dubai from time to time to meet his wife and kids. Again this is something I don’t understand, the fact that my uncle was able to travel but kept it a secret from my father. Perhaps his wife’s hold on him was too strong.
  • On one of my uncle’s trips in Jan, 2020, while he was in a bus returning from Dubai to Yemen, he quietly passed away on his bus seat. Just a day before his death he has sent a video message to my father, telling him that he loved him, and he was thinking of visiting him soon. Unfortunately my father never got the chance to open that message. He got the news of the death before that and had a full mental breakdown afterwards. (That message is something I found only much later on my father’s phone. I have still kept that message hidden from him until now).
  • My uncle’s body stayed in the morgue of an old run-down hospital in Yemen for days, as there was no next of kin to take it. My father, despite his poor state of mind, begged me to bring him the body of his brother. I tried my best but realized it was impossible, mainly due to lack of any flights or a functioning govt there. I did find people who wanted to charge me US5000$ to personally transport the body. I was willing to pay but turned out they were scammers and I was afraid that ultimately the body would be thrown down in a ditch somewhere.
  • In the end, the only option was to have him buried there by the locals. The wife (who was still in Dubai) sent her son back to Yemen (several days later) to bury my uncle and perhaps pick up any useful stuff my uncle had left behind in his apartment. The wife/son still haven’t told us where they buried my uncle. This is another blow, because my father may never even get the chance to visit his brother’s grave (to offer his prayers), even if the flights were to resume some day, and my father’s health allowed him to travel (which is unlikely).
  • So, that’s story of two brothers who never quite got the chance to be happy together. After a lifelong struggle and secret meetings for decades, my father lost his brother, who he hadn’t seen in 10 years and may never see again, not even his grave.
23 Likes

They wanted a single certificate for a six month old? Are these government workers mentally retarded?

7 Likes

For the most part…
They follow a checklist and if you ask for something that doesn’t follow the checklist their brains error out and explode.

The ability to pass a very hard rote exam doesn’t translate into big picture ability. The people that have the ability to see the big picture can’t get hired as the exam screens them out. I’ve met a few smart government workers before but they are hamstrung by the rulebook.

6 Likes

Reads like a novel.

6 Likes

Please write a book I want to read more. Can’t stop thinking about an old Yemeni friend who eat nothing but loaf with honey.

Good luck with everything, hope you soon have Taiwan written on your green passport.

5 Likes

I have nothing to offer but my hopes that all goes well from now on for you and your family.
Thanks for sharing your stories with us. Your perseverance is admirable, and it seems you got it from your dad. I wish him a well and fast recovery.

9 Likes

Well to be honest, my first visit to the HHRO was 2 weeks after the birth of my daughter, so technically the first time they asked me for a “single certificate” was when she was only 2 weeks old. I was extremely upset. I really wanted to punch someone there. Luckily, I controlled myself, realizing that those officers are just “following the rules”, and in Taiwan when something isn’t “explicitly” ruled out in the law, people here prefer to be “safe” rather than use common sense.

1 Like

Exactly!

2 Likes

Jesus hell of a story. So many words and stuff. I don’t think we’ve ever seen the likes of it on the Flob. :notworthy:

2 Likes

there should be a line written somewhere. Maybe the youngest age for a legal marriage amongst all the countries could be? They exempt health check for kids, so could do similar for other things.

Hope things will go well.

1 Like

Thank you, I would one day if I can. Just need to improve my writing skills a bit.

You just reminded me about Yemeni honey and how delicious it was. I still remember one of the top stores in the capital city which would always be filled with foreign tourists, especially from China.

In 6 years, so far I haven’t come across any person from Yemen here. Seems they are elusive. I would love to have a chat with one. In fact, feel more Yemeni than a Pakistani. I was taken to Yemen when I was only 3 months old. I’ve spent much of my life there. I used to be fluent in Yemeni style Arabic, but I’ve been losing it now that I haven’t spoken to anyone from Yemen in 10 years.

Thank you. Can’t wait for that day! Hope I can succeed in getting it before China invades and start rounding up all the foreigners.

Thank you for your kind wishes. I hope I can bring him back here someday so I can care for him. It would be great if Taiwan one day resumes giving out ARCs to parents of naturalized citizens. Currently my only hope is this:

NDC foreign professionals - draft bill

A new bill that I believe will become the law in 2021. There is one unexpected rule here, which says that if a Gold Card ARC holder becomes a naturalized Taiwanese citizen, then they can continue to keep some of the benefits of the Gold Card ARC, specifically their parents/lineal-family-members can continue to get 1 year-stay visas.

I’ll be honest, this does look unfair, because it will effectively create two categories of naturalized citizens. However, I desperately need this, so I would rather they extend this “family visa benefit” to every naturalized citizen rather than remove it from GC-holders-naturalized citizens too.

1 Like

I don’t know the criteria, but there is an option to call parents for humanitarian reasons. It is handled case by case.

2 Likes

TECO Manila now only accepts documents for authentication by a phone appointment. I called them last week to setup an appointment for my agent (strangely the agent could never get through :thinking:). Here’s how the conversation went:

TECO: What document do you want authenticated?
Me: My daughter’s CENOMAR.

CENOMAR => No marriage certificate in Philippines.

TECO: We have xx available date for her to visit.
Me : We will use an agent in Manila. My daughter and I are both in Taiwan. We can’t come in person.

TECO: Make sure your agent has an authenticated “letter of authority”, which is signed by your daughter, in the presence of an officer at the Philippines Embassy in Taiwan.
Me : My daughter can’t write/sign a letter of authority. She is a baby.

TECO : (Gasps) OMG ! How old is she ?
Me : 13 months.

TECO : Why do you need CENOMAR for a BABY !!
Me : I am applying for Taiwanese citizenship and my daughter is a minor accompanying me on the application. This is a requirement from the Taiwanese government.

TECO : Wait, I need to get my supervisor.
Me : Okay

I hear them gasping and talking in the background for a couple of minutes. I also hear a few laughs.

TECO (supervisor) : Excuse me, what’s the problem?
Me : I need TECO to authenticate my daughter’s CENOMAR. She is 1 year old.

TECO (supervisor) : Are you Taiwanese ?
Me : No, I am from Pakistan. My wife is a Filipino. I am applying for Taiwanese citizenship along with my daughter.

TECO (supervisor) : We can’t authenticate CENOMAR for a baby. We’ve have never done this before. Who asked you for this ?
Me : Ministry of Interior in Taiwan

TECO (supervisor) : Do you have proof?
Me : Yes. I exchanged emails with them. I tried to convince them but they insisted that I get this from Philippines. Also, it’s a part of the official list of naturalization requirements.

TECO (supervisor) : I will give you an appointment now but I am not sure about your case. Please send us all the proof from Taiwan govt. , including the emails via your agent. We will review your case on Dec 29.

5 Likes

This is a great option! I will definitely look in to it. I will search Forumosa to see if anyone has been successful with this.

For underage children a parent with custody has the authority to issue “letter of authority” to agent. You should be your child’s legal representative.
No?

2 Likes

In Chinese

若是外籍配偶有特殊考量,父母需要來台定居,移民署會依據人道需求個案處理,

1 Like

Your daughter should not need a single certificate:

“五、附繳其父母雙方或法定代理人同意證明。該未婚未成年男子年滿
18 歲、女子年滿 16 歲者,並檢附駐外館處認證及外交部複驗(驗
證)之婚姻狀況證明。”

Source: http://www-ws.pthg.gov.tw/Upload/2015pthg/oldfile/UserFiles/準歸化國籍(準歸化之未婚未成年子女,申請隨同歸化).pdf

3 Likes

Unfortunately it is an old version.

更新日期:101.07.05

They actually made worse their regulation on this.

2 Likes

Thank you for this epic post. It really puts the daily struggles most of us experience in perspective. :open_mouth:

5 Likes